The MovieMusic Store shopping cart   |  sign in
    SEARCH  
  • Home
  • Browse Store
    • New Soundtrack CDs
    • Top Sellers
    • Low Price New CDs
    • Used CDs
    • Soundtrack Compilations
    • Score Composers
    • Soundtrack Labels
    • Soundtracks by Year
    • ... detailed search page
  • Store Info
    • Happy Customers!
    • $1 Shipping
    • Accepted Payment Methods
    • Safe Shopping Guarantee
    • Shipping Rates & Policies
    • Our Privacy Policy
    • About Us
  • Help Center
    • My Account
    • How to Order
    • Search Tips
    • Return/Refund Policy
    • Cancelling Your Order
    • Contact the Store
  • The Lobby
  •   Message Boards
      Just Movies!
      How Many Hitchcock References ARE THERE in "WHAT LIES BENEATH"? (SPOILERS!)

    Archive of old forum. No more postings.

    Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.

    Author
    Topic:   How Many Hitchcock References ARE THERE in "WHAT LIES BENEATH"? (SPOILERS!)

     Chris Kinsinger
     Click Here to Email Chris Kinsinger
     Standard Userer
     

    FINAL WARNING!

    IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN "WHAT LIES BENEATH" GET OUTTA HERE RIGHT NOW!

    OUT!

    IF YOU PASS THIS POINT, SHUT YER TRAP!!!


    I LOVE this movie, and ever since seeing it, Bonita & I have been going over the many references to Hitchcock's Psycho.

    First of all, there's "Norman", who has a problem with Daddy. Seems that Daddy died in an automobile accident some time ago. Why even Norman's wife Claire nearly perished in a terrible auto collision awhile back!
    Later we learn that Norman's paramour, Madison Frank, also died in an automobile accident. And of course we ultimately learn that Norman is responsible for racking up that impressive pile of bodies at the bottom of the lake.
    When the drugged Claire falls from the bathtub, clinging to the clear plastic shower curtain, it's a shot-for-shot Psycho moment.
    Alan Silvestri's score is deliberately (and quite effectively) Herrmannesque, specifically Psycho Herrmannesque.
    And then there are the Rear Windowmoments, as Claire spies on her neighbors, and naturally one of them spies right back, ala Raymond Burr!

    So...how many other Hitch references are there in this movie?

    Which ones did I miss?

    ANYBODY?


    NP: Gladiator I LOVE this music!


    [This message has been edited by Chris Kinsinger (edited 27 July 2000).]

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-27-2000 08:36 PM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Standard Userer
     

    This might be a bit of a stretch, and I haven't seen the older movie in a million years, but wasn't there a brief reference to DIAL M FOR MURDER? Claire's doppelganger aiming for the letter opener ...

    I was particularly struck by the sheer volume of MIRROR shots in WHAT LIES BENEATH, which are difficult to photograph and which might have been a reference to one or another Hitch pic I'm not familiar with.

    I really didn't think the picture was all that Hitchcockian, myself. The REAR WINDOW references (not many) were completely obvious, but by and large, if anything, I was reminded more of DePalma (I know, he's supposed to be nothing more than a Hitchcock manque, but I've always thought he was more than that, myself.)

    (whoops, one more thought: when Ford & Pfeiffer were sparring, I kept thinking of GASLIGHT more than anything else.)

    [This message has been edited by H Rocco (edited 27 July 2000).]

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-27-2000 08:56 PM PT (US)     

     Luscious Lazlo
     Click Here to Email Luscious Lazlo
     Standard Userer
     

    Chris, I'm glad you warned me about the spoilers. I don't watch movies myself, but I read a lot of paperback novelizations. And WHAT LIES BENEATH is next on my list. (Right after I get thru reading TEEN WOLF TOO.)

    I have nothing but absolute contempt for movies that make cutesy-poo references to other entertainment. These showbiz people are so hideously inbred, it makes me vomit myself hollow. The all-time crappiest Hitchcock reference was done by DePalma in CARRIE. "Bates High School". Which is painfully obvious and pathetic.

    Rocco, you have probably already read THE ART OF ALFRED HITCHCOCK by Donald Spoto. Regarding PSYCHO, Spoto talks about the mirror fetishism. And about the deliberate look-alike casting of John Gavin & Anthony Perkins.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-29-2000 10:42 AM PT (US)     

     Chris Kinsinger
     Click Here to Email Chris Kinsinger
     Standard Userer
     

    Methinks Luscious is pulling my leg about never watching movies...and about Teen Wolf Too! That is a fascinating tidbit about mirror images...
    Rocco, I don't find anything particularly Hitchcockian about What Lies Beneath with the exception of all the references I mentioned.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-29-2000 03:36 PM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Standard Userer
     

    I didn't either ... I was stretching.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-29-2000 06:05 PM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Standard Userer
     

    Lazlo, I wonder if you've read BOTH versions of FRIDAY THE 13TH PART 3. Of all the movies to have been novelized twice! But it was ...

    Be sure to tell us what you made of TEEN WOLF TOO. I could never track that one down.

    NP: booktape version of the novelization of I STILL KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER, read by Jerry Van Dyke

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-29-2000 10:10 PM PT (US)     

     Luscious Lazlo
     Click Here to Email Luscious Lazlo
     Standard Userer
     

    FROM *THE ART OF ALFRED HITCHCOCK* BY DONALD SPOTO:

    "A further indication that the film is about the viewer, and that the several persons in the story represent different aspects of the viewer's mind, is the constant use of mirrors in the decor...But the most terrifying use of the mirror in PSYCHO is reserved for the sequence in which Lila Crane searches the Bates house: in Mother's room, she (and we) are terrified when wardrobe and vanity mirrors suddenly flash a double reflection of her."

    "What we are really frightened by is the alarming suggestion that we all have split personalities to some degree, that we can be different people at different times...When the car sticks in the mire momentarily, we feel Norman's nervousness, and we are relieved with him when it finally sinks into the dark water in a bubbly swallow. We want Norman---as we wanted Marion---to escape with impunity. Norman smiles out at us approvingly, and the sequence fades out."

    "The exchanges between Sam and Lila reinforce the visual parallels between Sam and Norman, whose profiles, hair, and coloring seem strikingly similar because of the way they are photographed."

    FROM *CONFESSIONS OF A CULTIST* BY ANDREW SARRIS: "In PSYCHO, if you recall, there is a moment after Tony Perkins has run Janet Leigh's car into a swamp when the car stops sinking. One could almost hear the audience holding its breath until the car resumed its descent below the surface. At that first intake of breath the audience became implicated in the fantasy of the perfect crime."

    NP: Audio-book of TO THE STARS by George Takei.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-30-2000 07:12 PM PT (US)     

     Chris Kinsinger
     Click Here to Email Chris Kinsinger
     Standard Userer
     

    That's great stuff, Luscious!
    Thanks for adding it in!

    I just recalled another Psycho reference in What Lies Beneath! Michelle Pfeiffer BACKS down the stairway, ala Martin Balsam!

    NP: The AudioNovel of The Big Lebowski,read by John Goodman.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-30-2000 08:37 PM PT (US)     

     JoeInSanDiego
     Click Here to Email JoeInSanDiego
     Standard Userer
     

    Since there are SPOILERS WARNINGS at the top, I don't feel bad about saying what I am about to say...so everyone who still has not seen this movie....STOP READING!!!!!


    I also loved this movie, although my date said it was the most boring peice of trash this year. I was NOT amused. Last date for ME..hehehe...in ANY event...

    The film was ALL ABOUT genre...it hit on every cliche imaginable, and yet this didn't bother me in the least. What I think I loved MOST was the fact that we get an actor we associate with heroism and daring deeds and, for the first time that I can recall, discover he is the villian of the piece (again, the plot was expected, although I found myself NOT wanting to believe it because, well, dammit, it's Harrison Ford!!!). A nice twist for me.

    Alan Silvestri's score was SPARSE...a wonderful addition to the film when it showed up with an excellent sense of eerieness that I totally enjoyed.

    Okay, let me know if you all agree with any of that or if I am way off base here.

    HUGS TO ALL.

    Joe

    NP American Beauty - T. Newman

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-31-2000 08:27 AM PT (US)     

     Chris Kinsinger
     Click Here to Email Chris Kinsinger
     Standard Userer
     

    I'm with you, Joe!
    All of the clues were right there in front of me, but I still didn't realize that Norman was a killer, because...well, like you said...it's Harrison Ford! The President! Indiana Jones! Mr. All-American Good Guy!

    My wife, however, KNEW that Norman had faked his electrocution right away, so she wasn't at all surprised, although she enjoyed the film just as much as I did.

    The introduction of the ghost was just enough to throw me off the trail...after all, I convinced myself that this was a "Ghost Story", not a murder mystery!

    D-OH!

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-31-2000 08:43 AM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Standard Userer
     

    I didn't see the twist with Ford coming at all -- largely because he has seemed so INSISTENT on protecting his image and never stretching an inch. This is certainly the best piece of acting he's done since THE MOSQUITO COAST (a quasi-villain), and I found it breathtaking that the picture nearly turned around in the last half hour to suggest the WHOLE THING, ghosts and all, was a setup. And what Ford's character must have been thinking throughout the movie -- this is a rare big-budget Hollywood picture that bases so much of its story on internal motivations, things we can only guess at or barely glimpse. It would have been just as interesting as a novel, and few screenplays are (it's just the nature of the format -- scripts are a lot easier to write on the whole, but probably not one of this kind. Unless you're someone like Neil Jordan or the Coen Bros., whose scripts are incredibly spare on the printed page, and then jump to amazingly detailed life when they direct them, but then it is probably just as hard to achieve such a pared-down style as it would be to craft something more ornate. Never mind, I'm off topic, I'll stop now.)

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-31-2000 01:57 PM PT (US)     

     Chris Kinsinger
     Click Here to Email Chris Kinsinger
     Standard Userer
     

    Pour forth, Rocco!
    Heck! That was only one paragraph! The written equivalent of Daniel2 opening his mouth to speak!



    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-31-2000 07:09 PM PT (US)     

     SBD
     Standard Userer
     

    [SPOILERS!]

    Just thought I'd get that out of the way.

    Now, in reverse chronological order:

    FAMILY PLOT - the seance and the possible presence of ghosts
    FRENZY - corpse found in the water
    PSYCHO - the bathtub (natch) and parts of Alan Silvestri's fine score
    VERTIGO - two different female characters who look a good deal alike (except that they're played by two different actresses instead of the same one in Vertigo - hey, I SAID [SPOILERS!])
    SHADOW OF A DOUBT - someone close turns out to be a killer
    and finally, virtually all of Hitch's major works are referenced by this simple fact: two of the film's stars (Michelle Pfeiffer and Amber Valletta) are blondes.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-06-2000 11:24 AM PT (US)     

     SBD
     Standard Userer
     

    I can't believe I forgot REAR WINDOW; it's one of the more pronounced Hitchcock references.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-06-2000 11:26 AM PT (US)     

     SBD
     Standard Userer
     

    What happened here? This was a pretty good topic.

    NP - Genocide *****/*****

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-09-2000 05:14 AM PT (US)     

     JoeInSanDiego
     Click Here to Email JoeInSanDiego
     Standard Userer
     

    And although CAPE FEAR is not a Hitchcock film, Silvestri quotes it at least one (obviously)...so there is INDEED the Herrmann connection going...

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-10-2000 09:16 AM PT (US)     
     

    Old Infopop Software by UBB

    © 1998-2011, The MovieMusic Company