-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Mychael Danna's REGENERATION
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Mychael Danna's REGENERATION

franz_conrad

Standard Userer

Searching for any reference to this score in this message board's history led me to conclude that it had gone completely unnoticed here. In fact, one of the few threads where it is mentioned is one where I'm embarrassed to encounter lengthy diatribes from the 'me of 2003' on why the music of LORD OF THE RINGS is better than STAR WARS. (These days my posts to such a thread would look more like Dinko's in that thread. Interesting how short a time it takes to become your own enemy.)In any case, I haven't seen the Gilles Mackinnon film that this score accompanied. It was lost in the clamour of press that greeted the mawkish 'film to end all wars' SAVING PRIVATE RYAN, but from the sound of it, traded high-tech film-making for a more novel approach to one of the 20th century's great wars. The novel the film is based on centres on a possible (fictional?) trenchline friendship of poets Wilfred Owen and Siegfried Sassoon, the former of whom was killed in battle. I missed the opportunity to see the film on release, as I still thought of movie going as a social experience, and my friendships of the time steered me clear of the film. It may well have emerged on DVD in Australia, but my bad reaction to Mackinnon's subsequent HIDEOUS KINKY, a film I was probably too close-minded to appreciate at the time, kept me from seeking it out. More shame. If the film ever was on DVD here, it's out of print now. (I may order the region 2 DVD.)
The score by Mychael Danna has definitely won my heart though. Danna's often made marvelous use of solo violin parts in scores, and perhaps his most touching positions a soloist against a reserved ensemble for 'Garden of Death'. Funereal is the word I would use to describe the use of organ, oboe and vocalist in 'The Gamekeeper's Traps'. The main theme from 'Garden of Death' appears in many guises - from the lonely trumpets of 'Declaration' to the clarinet of 'Skulls like Mushrooms' and the grainy fiddle of 'Do Write Something about the War'. A gentle melody with a Celtic lilt offers a few lighter moments - 'Dottyville' and 'Toy Boats' - the latter's texture of flute, harp and pizzicati a nice contrast to the bleak surrounds.
For those who were moved by 'Elegy for Dunkirk' from the recent Oscar winner ATONEMENT, this music taps into some very similar emotions, though is perhaps a little more restrained (less epiphany) and the score is considerably less Romantic as a whole. Like that cue, this score feels like it taps into some 'British' tradition of composition (Britten, Holst and others come to mind) that I'm not musically equipped to describe properly.
The Varese Sarabande disc has only 30 minutes of music, a typically short but emotionally complete effort from the composer. The remaining eight minutes of the running time is taken up with readings of Sassoon and (to me) the more chilling poetry of Owen, whose battle-weariness and gift for language created such memorable metaphors as "the shrill, demented choirs of wailing shells". It doesn't necessarily strengthen the album throughout, but the balance (unlike the recent CAPOTE) is weighted firmly in favour of the score. The use the poems throughout does the lay the foundation for the album's concluding track, which utilises a moving monologue from the film, followed by Owen's 'The Parable of the Old Man and Young' over a bleak processional beat. On the poem's devastating conclusion, a reprise of 'Garden of Death' brings the album to a close.
What else is there to say about REGENERATION, one of the most overlooked scores of the 90s, but the opinion of its creator (c.2006)? (From an email in response to an article I wrote on Danna which mentioned the score as an overlooked highlight.)
quote:
Noone seems
to know that film, certainly in North America, and it's one of my favourites, both the film and the score. Probably my "one filmscore you did that you can take with you to a desert island" choice.Although it might make it a pretty dark time on that island.
[Message edited by franz_conrad on 03-11-2008]
posted 03-11-2008 05:25 PM PT (US) 
nuts_score

Standard Userer

I guess you've intrigued me, but how dare you claim that LotR is a more cohesive listening and musically aesthetic experience than the best scores of all goddamn time, Star Wars!!!!!!!!!! Where's your head at you fraud?! Turn in your film music lover badge and your gun and get the hell out of my office you sorry sack of koala doo! If I were you I would never show my ugly-ass face around these parts; ever again! You hear me?! I hope Peter bans you, Michael.You make me sick.
posted 03-11-2008 06:51 PM PT (US) 
nuts_score

Standard Userer

On a lighter note, I never thought that Danna wouldn't take the time to have proper spelling and puncutation in his emails. He's dropped a notch below his brother, IMHO. My emails from Marco Beltrami and Brian Tyler all had great grammar.
NP> Howard Shore's SUN: Soul of the Ultimate Nation (*****/*****)
posted 03-11-2008 06:54 PM PT (US) 
franz_conrad

Standard Userer

How did I know that the only replies to this thread would have more to do with that old LOTR vs STAR WARS thread than Danna's REGENERATION. I feel like a film-maker who tries to capture some interest by having a line of toys made from his characters.EDIT - Ah, I see the composer's spelling is more interesting than the score. I better fix that up.
[Message edited by franz_conrad on 03-11-2008]
posted 03-11-2008 06:55 PM PT (US) 
nuts_score

Standard Userer

John Williams - 1Michael McLennan - 0
Read it and weap, bitch. Now maybe you'll think twice before posting such blasphemy. Next you'll tell me that Howard Shore is better than uber-mensch Ken Thorne! I think you're lucky that you didn't post this phoney non-sense on FSM. They would've eaten you like a hamburger with pepper jack cheese and onion rings.All hail Sir John Williams, Composer Supreme!
posted 03-11-2008 07:03 PM PT (US) 
franz_conrad

Standard Userer

I appreciate you keeping this thread bobbing at the top of the forum, Andrew, I really do.Therefore, I will 'weap'.
posted 03-11-2008 07:10 PM PT (US) 
nuts_score

Standard Userer

W - Wish
E - Evil
A - Against
P - PeterK
Bumpy, bump.posted 03-12-2008 12:45 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
