quote:

---

Originally posted by Mark Olivarez:
I wouldn't say The Omen falls into the category of bad films but I will say Goldsmith might be the front runner for great scores / bad films.

---

FALL, on the other hand, has got so much good in it from amazing performances by Alec Guinness (saluting the visiting tribunes) and James Mason (standing up to torture) to great action scenes (chariot chases and hand-to-hand combat) to wonderful bits of atmosphere (chariots in the snow, torches at the funeral procession, etc. etc. etc.).

Anthony Mann is a great director and he did a solid job of this. My main problem with the film is that the third act seems rushed. The film clocks in at 161 minutes so they were probably cutting everything in sight before the premiere. Sophia Loren and Stephen Boyd don't see eye to eye about the succession, so she starts a civil war and then despite the clash of armies and thousands dead, it seems to get resolved with no harm done to her or their relationship, and then they both return to Rome where a whole lot of loose ends have to be tied up in the last 15 minutes.

So, it's not quite his best film and it's not quite a masterpiece (though someone who wrote a book on Mann considered it both) but I simply can't think of Mann's best 10 works without including it.

And for the record the top 10 Mann would be (not in any rank or order):

Generally, Goldsmith and Zimmer have scored some really bad movies, but composed incredibly good scores for them—scores that those film never deserved.