-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Philippe Sarde's GHOST STORY
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Philippe Sarde's GHOST STORY

Ken S

Romulan

I recently spent some extended time watching and analyzing GHOST STORY (1981) and comparing it to Peter Straub's original novel - and I came to the conclusion that the movie is actually BETTER than the original novel.It's somehow ironic that some non-film-music-fan people, with whom I have discussed about this score, have the opinion that GHOST STORY has a bad score because the music is almost all the time "in your face". I have even myself thought previously that in some sequences Sarde's music is definitely a little bit "out from the place" - but when I recently read the novel again, more carefully than before, and compared it to the movie, it all started to make sense - even Sarde's music.
In the novel Straub, believe it or not, USES MUSIC in some "spook scenes" - there seems to be a "musical motif" linked to a zombie army, wherever they go (just like the shark has in JAWS)...
So, it really starts to make sense - although the movie is VERY different from the novel, and so is the music - that Sarde's score really pays a "hidden respect" to Straub's original text in this way.
Plus, when I started to compare Sarde's gorgeous GHOST STORY score to Williams' JAWS, I even made a truly important discovery. Previously I have thought that, despite it's beautiful music, Sarde's GHOST STORY score is a little predictable by its way of repeating the same fright motifs throughout the movie. But only now, some 12 years later, I finally realized that in fact Sarde uses the motifs ingeniously: He deliberately introduces these motifs VERY WELL to the audience in the beginning of the movie, so extra tension is easily achieved throughout the movie when the audience thinks that "oooo, watch out, here the music comes again!" - but then, when the musical climax SHOULD come, it doesn't. Splendid reverse musical psychology, if you ask me !!

After almost 22 years, GHOST STORY the movie is still one of the best spook films ever made - and the score is gorgeous.
Clicking the link you can see one other reason why I love this specific movie - however, BE WARNED: THE LINKED DOCUMENT INCLUDES SOME VERY GRUESOME IMAGES that have the power to haunt you forever.
http://www.kolumbus.fi/kenneth.sundberg/fav_ghostory.html
KENposted 03-08-2003 03:13 PM PT (US) 
rkeaveney

Romulan

The only thing that haunts me about GHOST STORY is when that guy goes for a freefall out of the apartment building... Nude.That ain't a towel flapping in the wind...
Ryan
posted 03-08-2003 10:00 PM PT (US) 
JJH

Romulan

not even Alice Krige nude throughout most of the movie haunts you?posted 03-08-2003 10:28 PM PT (US) 
LRobHubbard

Romulan

My response to your supposition that the movie version of GHOST STORY is better than the novel is what the hell were you smoking when you made the comparison?... and where can I get some of it? It's obviously a hallucinogen.GHOST STORY (the movie) manages to waste a good cast and score, due to the fact that the adaptation takes the lame road and turns what should have been one of the best horror films of the century into a tepid exercise, where the only memorable things are rot effects by Dick Smith, and the nudity of Alice Krige (plus Craig Wasson's nude window plunge at the beginning of the film).
The fault is mainly in Lawrence Cohen's script, which drastically simplifies the Straub novel - not a good decision in this case. (despite his script for DePalma's film of CARRIE, Cohen's adaptation of other King/horror work is less than stellar - take his adaptation of King's TOMMYKNOCKERS and IT, which also suffer from oversimplification).
posted 03-10-2003 05:43 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
