-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Best of the Summer anyone?
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Best of the Summer anyone?

TV's Frank

Goldmember

Well, as I see no one else has started such as thread and now that summer is officially over, what was everyone's top five scores of the summer?I'm still thinking about what mine would be, but feel free to respond!

posted 09-03-2002 09:42 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Goldmember

Summer isn't officially over until Sep. 23.
posted 09-03-2002 10:16 AM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Goldmember

What? You're kidding! Well, how about we just pretend, since the summer MOVIE season has expired!I think I'll list as my favorites, SIGNS, SW-AOTC, REIGN OF FIRE and I'm still thinking about two others...
posted 09-03-2002 10:45 AM PT (US) 
justin boggan

Goldmember

SignsAustin Powers 3
Spider-Man
2nd place goes to Men In Black 2. Which is beeter than the first score, not counting the amazing main and end titles.
posted 09-03-2002 11:11 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Goldmember

Haven't heard many summer scores yet. AOTC is a good one, and I'm told Minority Report will be much better once I've seen the movie (still not out here).Sum of All Fears was nice, though overly clicheed in parts. Will get the CD someday, but probably won't buy full price for it.
Spider-Man was a really bad score.
posted 09-03-2002 11:35 AM PT (US) 
Camillu

Goldmember

Signs
Spiderman
AOTC
Road to PerditionHaven't heard Reign of Fire yet...
posted 09-03-2002 11:45 AM PT (US) 
jeffy

Goldmember

Signs
Road to Perdition
Minority ReportThe rest of the scores are just OK. Attack of the Clones is good, but I'm still not crazy about the musical choices in the last 10 minutes.
posted 09-03-2002 12:19 PM PT (US) 
MillsSomerset
Goldmember

Best Scores:ROAD TO PERDITION (hasn't left my cd player since June)
AOTC
INSOMNIA
SUM OF ALL FEARS
and
MINORITY REPORT (which would place higher, if more tracks had been like the 2nd half of the first cue...still, I think Williams has outdone himself w/this and AOTC in the same summer, much less the same year, so he earns my pick for "Summer MVP" by far)Best Collection of Songs: UNDERCOVER BROTHER
Best Theme: "Across the Stars", AOTC
Best Trailer Music To Wind Up In the Final Film: SIGNS
Most Improved: Randy Edeleman, XXX (what little of it I could make out over all the noise and Rammstein, I actually dug)
Worst Score: 2-way tie
SERVING SARAH (easily the most aggressively awful romantic comedy score I've heard in recent memory; I mean, IMO, all one has to do is listen to some James Newton Howard DAVE/MY BEST FRIEND'S WEDDING-type stuff to hear how it could be done right, pleasantly, and memorably)
and
PLUTO NASH (and just when I thought Powell was on an upswing, though I think this had more to do w/the crappiness of the movie - how can one be inspired to write anything good for this?)
Just my humble opinions. Peace.
posted 09-03-2002 12:24 PM PT (US) 
jeffy

Goldmember

quote:
Originally posted by MillsSomerset:
MINORITY REPORT (which would place higher, if more tracks had been like the 2nd half of the first cue
Well, the first cue is actually the film's end credits, which would be a melding of the film's major themes, so most of the tracks are indeed like the 2nd half of the first cue.quote:
...still, I think Williams has outdone himself w/this and AOTC in the same summer, much less the same year, so he earns my pick for "Summer MVP" by far)Oh yeah, I agree with you there.
posted 09-03-2002 02:31 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little
Goldmember

The one "summer" score I purchased was Sum of All Fears. I like it, but I have to be honest that I haven't given it many plays in the past couple of months.
posted 09-03-2002 02:39 PM PT (US) 
SBD
Goldmember

Note that these were based on the films I saw:1. Lilo and Stitch (Alan Silvestri)
2. Scooby-Doo (David Newman; come on, Academy promo!)
3. Spider-Man (Danny Elfman)
4. Undercover Brother (Stanley Clarke; a nice collection of orchestra and '70s funk that deserves a release)
5. Men in Black II (Danny Elfman)posted 09-03-2002 03:42 PM PT (US) 
Timmer

Goldmember

Marian said...
Spider-Man was a really bad score.[/B][/QUOTE]
Totally agree! This was a missed opportunity, Spidey should have had a proper score with proper themes, not something you should have to strain to hear...Danny E, unfortunately was a bad BAD choice for composer IMHO!NP - La Mer - Debussy - Ernest Ansermet
[Message edited by Timmer on 09-03-2002]
posted 09-03-2002 05:07 PM PT (US) 
nightwing

Goldmember

I would say either Road to Perdition or Signs as the best. Amazingly both are on my desk as I type. I just saw Austin Powers a second time and I must say it was a really good score.
posted 09-03-2002 09:03 PM PT (US) 
Camillu

Goldmember

quote:
Originally posted by Timmer:
[B]
Spidey should have had a proper score with proper themes, not something you should have to strain to hear...Excuse the excess wit, but if your stereo isn't on mute, you should be able to hear the theme in just about every track. The main one that is - cos there are others.
It's Iron Giant all over again...
posted 09-04-2002 01:28 AM PT (US) 
SFT

Goldmember

Spiderman a bad score? Well, some people just have BAD taste. And to say that it is themeless is basically to admit that you are deaf.SFT
posted 09-04-2002 02:47 AM PT (US) 
justin boggan

Goldmember

Okay, we get it- some people don't like Elfman. I myself hate some of his scores. The worse that comes to mind is Dick Tracy.But even if you hate his work for Spider-MAn, i am totally surprised you did not hear the theme. I is like almost everywhere.
posted 09-04-2002 05:12 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Goldmember

quote:
Originally posted by Camillu:
Excuse the excess wit, but if your stereo isn't on mute, you should be able to hear the theme in just about every track.Re muting...my biggest problem with he score is that it was so loud. Fully blasting brass batteries for scenes that should have been scored softly, if at all. It really annoyed me in the film.
NP: Timmer's TV Themes Compilation
posted 09-04-2002 06:16 AM PT (US) 
Bulldog
Goldmember

S-I-G-N-S
posted 09-04-2002 10:23 AM PT (US) 
joan hue

Goldmember

I must be getting very picky as I really have NOT been thrilled with any score so far
this year. The older reissues have brought me more pleasure.Hey Timmer, I do agree with you about Spider Man. The movie demanded an
EVIDENT, well-articulated theme for Spidey AND a love theme that should have
taken on tragic proportions at the end. I know some of you say it has themes. I guess if I
wanted to listen to a stand alone CD several times, I could find one, but I don’t care to. I
didn’t stand up in the middle of SUPERMAN and yell, “Hey, rewind some of the movie so
I can see if I can hear is a theme for Superman. Here is Lois so please replay this part so
I can see if I can identify a love theme. Is there a theme for Lex???” Did anyone miss the
theme for the Vikings in The 13th Warrior? The workouts in Rudy? The shark in Jaws?
Indie’s main theme? I think movies about larger than life people need themes or melodies
people can actually HEAR during their viewing of the movies. (And I ain’t deaf.) Just my
humble opinion.The score I’ve enjoyed most this year is from last year’s rather poor Disney movie Snow
Dogs. Debney composes several marvelous compositions (action themes, comedic music,
Americana sounds, love themes, etc.) that are better than anything I’ve heard this year.
Oh, well, I have hope for the next four months.NP Birdman of Alcatraz
posted 09-04-2002 10:04 PM PT (US) 
Timmer

Goldmember

Danny Elfman may not be my favourite composer but I don't dislike or hate him, he's written plenty of scores that I enjoy and they get good playtime from me, however I just feel he wasn't right for Spiderman, his score certainly doesn't serve the film well, all that harsh brass and choirs?...yeachh! Unlike Batman this film had a brighter look (as it should considering were talking New York rather than 'Gotham' city) and should have had a lighter breezier score with a 'dare I say it' bit of a swing
what we have is a murky dark meandering quagmire of a score with very weak themes, it's Spidey fer cripes sake and Spidey needs a memorable theme, and a theme doesn't have to be big and bold as Superman to be 'in your face'! This is the worst score I've heard by Elfman and it only bothers me because I really enjoyed the film.Henry Mancini would have nailed this film spot on, Basil Poledouris or Lalo Schifrin would have been good choices (Basil's the only one who 'might' have had a shout here) as would Jerry Goldsmith!
Rant over, Nuff said
Tim
posted 09-05-2002 05:16 AM PT (US) 
SFT

Goldmember

That's funny, because "a lighter breezier score with a bit of a swing" is exactly what I hear. The score is not particularly dark as such if you actually listen to it, and the use of percussion and choir gives it a very distinctive tone which I thought fit the film well. We don't really need a downrigh leitmotif-theme for Spiderman. Why is it that people always want big, memorable themes? I really think you ruin the film, or at least the music, for yourself because you insist on sitting through the entire thing listening after something "catchy" or "hummable". Just admit it, you really WERE expecting a new Batman. Sorry, that wasn't what you got. Instead you got a score that really benefits the film far more than people realize, and while it certainly won't outlive Batman or Superman in popularity, it is just as fine a film score as has ever been written in the genre.SFT
[Message edited by SFT on 09-05-2002]
posted 09-05-2002 11:17 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
