-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
The Others, the others and THE OTHERS
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: The Others, the others and THE OTHERS

Ken S

Goldmember

I was going to write my own little review of Alejandro Amenábar's music for his own movie - but then I realized I've had my share of writing negative stuff on this site
so I didn't do it.But now I do it anyway
But for a reason.I've been listening to Amenábar's THE OTHERS for quite some time now. The point is that I truly adore his Main Title music ("The Others" on the CD) but can't understand why this marvelous composer's "turbulence" music lacks so much of melody (when the Main Title simply swarms with beautiful and mysterious notes). While all this horror and "turbulence" music works marvelously in the movie, on the soundtrack it isn't scary nor as atmospheric as with the images of the movie. - - WELL, AIN'T IT THE PURPOSE OF "MOVIE MUSIC"
?!!!!Amenábar is very original while writing the simple and beautiful themes - his Main Title in my opinion is something easily linked to European folklore and could easily underscore the dark but fantastic worlds of the fairytales by the Brothers Grimm. Yet it is quite a negative surprise that with his true "horror" and "turbulence" music he just can't be original enough - his score, which has been said to avoid any typical clichés, in my opinion sounds in most parts just like anything coming from Hollywood nowadays - loud, noisy, and lacking melody 'n' any originality. Which is a pity for a score that has such a MARVELOUS and SPELLBINDING Main Title theme.
Thus I started to think about movie music - on soundtracks - that truly HAS enough power to scare the socks off the listener's feet and yet be MELODIC and/or simply ORIGINAL. I haven't yet found any rivals for such splendidly CHILLING orchestral turbulence as David Shire's "Flight in the Storm" in RETURN TO OZ or John Williams' "Miracle of the Ark" in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, or most of the cues on Jerry Goldsmith's THE OMEN. But when talking about truly FRIGHTENING movie music, can there be more perfectly terrifying cue as James Horner's "Tarantula Attack" (the latter part of "The Dust Witch") in SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES, or something like Alan Silvestri's "Rest in Pieces" from PREDATOR 2 or Hans Zimmer's certain cues from PAPER HOUSE ??
So, let's go on a search for some TRULY frightening movie music - tell me what score cues have managed to scare your socks off !!
And please don't tell me that Amenábar's THE OTHERS is scary music

...I'd certainly like to know what kind of stuff the other THE OTHER(S) score includes - wasn't it by Jerry Goldsmith himself ?
KENNP. Something Wicked This Way Comes (1983, James Horner) - any Horner hater SHOULD get this score; it's terrific (...although it's a pity that Georges Delerue's rejected score included a much better Main Title).
posted 06-19-2002 09:41 AM PT (US) 
Mark Olivarez

Goldmember

"Barry's Abduction" from CE3K. When I was a young lad that cue used to scare me to death. It is still chilling to this day.
posted 06-19-2002 09:54 AM PT (US) 
Timmer

Goldmember

The Other was indeed composed by Goldsmith and is a nice little slice of Americana to be found on Varese's release of The Mephisto Waltz, as a film The Other is a little gem of a movie with a truly horrifying ending...try and see it sometime, if not I'm sure I could post you the video.
Chris Young's Hellraiser II is the scariest score IMO though I certainly agree with 'Barry's Abduction'.
posted 06-19-2002 10:34 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Goldmember

Loud isn't (necessarily) a bad thing. Noisy isn't (necessarily) a bad thing. And lack of melody certainly isn't (necessarily) a bad thing either.Plus, in the film, the score is as scary as it could be.
posted 06-19-2002 10:38 AM PT (US) 
Beatty

Goldmember

<BLOCKQUOTE><font size=1 face=arial>quote:</font><HR size=1>Originally posted by Ken S:
NP. Something Wicked This Way Comes (1983, James Horner) - any Horner hater SHOULD get this score; it's terrific (...although it's a pity that Georges Delerue's rejected score included a much better Main Title).[/b]<HR size=1></BLOCKQUOTE>Is this the SWTWC (warning! tacky!)that you mean?
Otherwise, I don't know where one would get this CD.
[Message edited by Beatty on 06-19-2002]
posted 06-19-2002 10:50 AM PT (US) 
juha

Goldmember

Almost everyhting in ALIEN. Bernard Herrmann's scores SISTERS, CAPE FEAR and PSYCHO are very chilling too. I've always wondered how could Herrmann write melodically so damn nerve wrecking music!
Barry's Kidnapping is also a superb cue.
And of course THE FURY!!!Regards, Juha.
posted 06-19-2002 11:26 AM PT (US) 
JJH

Goldmember

scariest score to come around in a LONG time is Brian Tyler's Frailty. that is one score that has a seriousness of purpose. It only exists to fill the listener with dread. And after repeated listenings, those orchestral hits are still shocking.See the movie when it comes out on DVD. I doubt you will ever see a darker film than Frailty.
NP -- The Black Stallion Returns, Delerueposted 06-19-2002 11:44 AM PT (US) 
percepto

Minimember

Excellent topic!Amenabar was kind enough to write the Afterword for our release of THE CHANGELING (Percepto 006). His notes certainly offer greater insight into his appreciation of scoring for a horror film.
Here are his notes in their entirety:
"The release of this recording is, for me, the fulfillment of an old dream, so old, in fact, that I had given it up as impossible. Many years have passed since I saw and heard The Changeling. The images and their underlying music made an indelible impression on my mind.There is something I find indisputable in Peter Medak’s picture, namely his ability to send a real shiver down your spine, the sort that has you teetering on the edge of a precipice, or in this case, on the edge of a staircase, and sends you plunging into the unknown. I consider that the music composed for The Changeling was fundamental in creating just such an atmosphere, and rarely have I found a soundtrack so suggestive and stimulating. Thanks to the solid simplicity of its concept carried principally by piano, strings and chorus, and its extremely elegant harmonies, The Changeling’s score succeeds in blending two elements which are difficult to unite in works of its nature: serene beauty and implacable efficacy. The astonishing melancholy of its main theme, a genuine masterpiece, gives sense to and is, in my opinion, the basis of one of the best horror movie soundtracks of all time."
Alejandro Amenabar, Director of The Others
September, 2001posted 06-20-2002 03:55 PM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Goldmember

I know what you mean, Ken. Amenábar did a beautiful Main Title for THE OTHERS, recalling Bernstein's delicate TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD and even some of Jerry Fielding's work in its solo passages. I like the rest of the score too, but it does seem a bit more run-of-the-mill horror in its dissonances. Sounds like it might have been mocked up on synth, there's not much orchestral complexity, though it has influences of everything, like Goldsmith's FREUD (or maybe that was the Bartok influence). Good score nonetheless.The other OTHER, as Timmer says, is an interesting film with a good, albeit brief, Goldsmith score. Some horror bits but mostly pastoral and yearning. Check out the Varese release, because it's got THE MEPHISTO WALTZ on it, which is one of the most genuinely scary scores I've ever heard.
posted 06-23-2002 10:03 AM PT (US) 
Ken S

Goldmember

Is there a waltz in MEPHISTO WALTZ ?
I'm just crazy about horror movie waltzes !!!!
KENposted 06-27-2002 12:45 PM PT (US) 
OHMSS76

Goldmember

Ken....four Essential horror film valzers
HELLRAISER (Resurrection) Gorgeous, malevolent piece by Chris Young for orchestra
FLOWERS IN THE ATTIC (The VCA Waltz) Marginally a horror film, but one of my all time favorite pieces of music, quietly moving, this has such a beautiful nocturnal beauty, my heart is thumping just thinking about....gorgeous cue for string quartet, harp and piano by Young.
TIME AFTER TIME (Time Machine Waltz) by Rozsa....again, marginal horror, but the music? See above!
BLOOD LINK-EXTRASENSSORIAL by Morricone....many waltz pieces in this horror score that is more elegant than horrific....although, as with many Ennio scores, it ends on a discordant cue.
Thanks a lot for getting me all mushy-like
Seanposted 06-27-2002 01:32 PM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Goldmember

Yes Ken, a very demonic version of the Liszt piece. You'll love it!
posted 06-27-2002 01:33 PM PT (US) 
Ken S

Goldmember

Thanks Sean and Graham
I simply NEED to get MEPHISTO WALTZ and the things you recommended, Sean (though I have the Hellraiser "Resurrection" waltz - simply magnificent) !!!
Does neither of you do any trades ??
KENposted 06-27-2002 03:25 PM PT (US) 
OHMSS76

Goldmember

Hi Ken
Of course I do trades!
Drop me an email, I would be MORE than happy to get a copy of the above(especially Flowers/Attic) to ya, I think you'd enjoy them

Sean
posted 06-27-2002 08:05 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
