-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
A Beautiful Mind
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: A Beautiful Mind

Hasta
Oscar® Winner

Back a few weeks ago when I obtained Horner's A Beautiful Mind, I commented that it was overlong and contained way too many self-rips... That fact still stands.Didn't get around to seeing the film till yesterday, however, and I must say a few things.
First off, the film blew me away. Maybe it's just the fact that Ron Howard tends to make nothing but overly mediocre films (yeah yeah, there's Apollo 13), or maybe it's because the Hollywood bullsh*t of the past two years has been absolute rubbish. Whatever the reason, this film had heart, wonderful performances, an interesting storyline and was just very well put together.
No, it wasn't anything new, but it was great nonetheless.
Then there was Horner's score; sometimes I don't know why I doubt this man. Sure, as an "artist", he is going further and further down the hill, but MAN does he know how to score a picture. Any who claims that his score wasn't effective here, well, I'd have a hard time reasoning with them... Low-key, tense and lovely at all the right moments, never overbearing... It worked wonders.
It still remains a "good" CD and nothing more for several reasons, but as heard in film, Horner's score is indeed "great".
I recommend you see the film if you haven't, if your expectations were anything like mine, you'll probably be pleasantly surprised.
[Message edited by Hasta on 01-13-2002]
posted 01-13-2002 05:41 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

Discovered once again why people should spend their $20 on a DVD with a James Horner score instead of a CD with a James Horner score. One feels much more satisfied with the exchange if the proper goods are involved.Of course, this only applies to James Horner most of the time. If it applied to all film music all the time, the MovieMusic Store wouldn't exist (except if it started selling DVDs.... hint hint!).
posted 01-13-2002 05:58 PM PT (US) 
James

Oscar® Winner

The film is on my long list of things I have to see right now. It shouldn't be too much longer before I catch it. Hearing that Horner's score works so well is encouraging.
posted 01-13-2002 07:06 PM PT (US) 
joan hue

Oscar® Winner

I really enjoyed A Beautiful Mind. Watch Crowe in L.A. Confidential with his
visceral, muscular body language that permeates all of his scenes, and then watch
the opposite body language in A Beautiful Mind. He truly inhabits this character
and is most deserving of an Oscar for this performance. For me, the only
weakness of the film was a rather mediocre music score. (Sorry Hasta, just my opinion.) This emotional movie
begged for the strong themes Horner wrote for movies like Legends of the Fall.
I heard nothing much in A Beautiful Mind that really moved me, but the acting on
the part of all characters was wonderful.
posted 01-13-2002 10:15 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
