-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Questions for "attached" collectors!
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Questions for "attached" collectors!

TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

This thread mainly concerns score collectors who are either married or living with their significant other and is a poll to determine how your listening habits have changed (or haven't, as the case may be) since the big move.
I currently live with my fiancé and find that I am unable to listen to as many albums as when I lived alone or had roommates. I think too much of only my music could be seen as selfish and self-indulgent. Also, I find that I'm more selective about what I play when she is around. For instance, she HATES Thomas Newman completely (she says his scores go nowhere musically), so he's out unless on headphones, but she makes up for that by liking all things Barry, even his jazzy 60's side!
I'm curious to know from other collectors how their listening habits have changed when living with a spouse or fiancé (someone more meaningful than a random roommate). Do you have a special listening room set up in the house or is there a shared stereo system? Do you find that certain scores are off limits when she or he is around (such as the aforementioned ban on Thomas Newman in my home)? Do find yourself being more self-conscious when playing scores you really like around them, unsure of whether or not they're annoyed?
See, I still live in a one-bedroom apartment, so there has to be some compromise, obviously. I think I just feel somewhat restricted at times in figuring out how much film music can she really tolerate and which scores irk her to no end.
So let me know people! Tell me stories! Do you have a listening schedule worked out with your spouse?
Thanks all!
posted 08-06-2001 03:53 PM PT (US) 
OHMSS76

Oscar® Winner

Great thread! It's about time someone did this!Congrats to ya B

I just got married last month myself, and my habits are just the same, since my wife likes 'my' music as it is anyway. There are only two things that have elicited a response....Phillip Glass' opera SATYAGRAHA(she calls his minimalistic whirlwinds 'messy music') and some of Morricone's 60's pop work. No bans yet though!
It is harder to focus on music when attatched to someone,since they tend to need more attention than music asks for. The hard part for me is balancing volume....we always have some score or music on in the car,at home, but finding the right volume so we can still talk and I can hear the stereo is hard sometimes. I guess you get used to it!
I wish I had more answers for you, but it depends on what the other half wants to hear(in my case, she doesn't listen to anything, and is happy with my stuff) and how much room you have to spread out(we also have a small one bedroom apt for now).
Cool thread though, I'll be curious to see what others think!
NP:Ivanhoe(Rozsa)
SeanPS...what does your lady think of Goldsmith? Thank God mine loves his work!Phew

posted 08-06-2001 04:07 PM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

Thanks for the response, Sean! Good to know what it is like for others! My fiance is actually a big music lover, but while she does enjoy orchestral music, she prefers solo artists, some French & Latin music, and more folksy kinda sounds. Not so intense as film scores can be!
I think she does like Goldsmith for the most part, if only because I reference him endlessly and she's going to hear his music the most often! She does enjoy FIRST KNIGHT, THE MUMMY and all his Western scores, which was really unexpected. She flipped when she first heard WILD ROVERS and 100 RIFLES and I thought this was a dream come true. Woman like Goldsmith - HOORAY!
I think she really admires his efforts to experiment and still retain a singular voice in film music. What an insightful gal I have!
posted 08-06-2001 04:19 PM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Oscar® Winner

I've been married 7 1/2 years now. My habits haven't changed at all, except for maybe listening to even more scores. My wife (girlfriend at the time) couldn't understand why anyone would want to listen to a music only soundtrack. Shortly after we started dating, she bought Jurassic Park for me because she knew I wanted it. She loved it herself. From there, the rest is history. She likes Williams, Horner, Zimmer. She doesn't really like the sci-fi or horror stuff I listen too, but she doesn't complain. As long as she can listen to her types also. And my almost 4 year old boy loves soundtracks. He tells me what's going on in the movie during the music. IT'S GREAT!! I guess I'm just fortunate with my wife. And now I have a 2 1/2 month old to turn to the soundtrack ways.
posted 08-06-2001 05:10 PM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

Yeah, Sebulba, start 'em young! I hope to have the same good luck when I have children, hopefully they'll find film music just as engaging!
posted 08-06-2001 08:02 PM PT (US) 
HadrianD

Oscar® Winner

I'm attached in the way that I'm getting "attached" to my sweety when I graduate college, and I'm soo lucky that my girl knows what I like and she'll listen until she can't handle it. But I make compromises by making her three CD-r of softer themes to listen to around the apartment
When I drive I'll listen to the more driving scores
To me, it's about compromises
posted 08-06-2001 09:06 PM PT (US) 
cine-sin

Oscar® Winner

I have been going out with the same person for 7 years now and when we first started living together - my listening habits did not change whatsoever.We both have seperate stereos although his never gets used audio-wise since he works long hours. He prefers to watch TV which I limit myself, since there's so much garbage about these days.
We have just moved into a new apartment and the guest bedroom has become my study where I also listen to music. Some months ago I posted a thread asking "What would your response be?"...when asked to stop collecting. Yes the person I passed off as my housemate is actually my partner. The reason I did this was because I didn't want lots of responses telling me to dump him...although some people did that anyway.
That time was the only time scores became an issue since we faced living in a smaller space. I have not stopped collecting but, on my own terms, decided to be more selective since trading is so completely addictive and I have so many scores I never really listen to. The issue has never been raised again...although he does remind me that we need yet another CD rack to accomodate the few hundred scores on the floor.
With reference to the car stereo...we share 3 discs each in the cartridge. With this in mind, I tend to make compilations of my fave music. I never feel self-conscious at all when playing scores because I know it doesn't bother him.
Perhaps the only time it did bother him was when he owned a very hoony car which was turbo charged and had wheels to break a bank account. It was loud and gutsy. It was awful. Anyway, I used to play scores and intitally I think he found it disconcerting to drive around in this testosterone vehicle while listening to Mozart-esque type music. It was an interesting contrast I can tell you.
That car is now history and I've managed to refine him a little...:-)
Regards,
Rochelleposted 08-07-2001 09:26 AM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

Thanks, Rochelle, for your input! That would be a tough choice if my fiance asked me to stop collecting, but seeing how highly she values music over other art forms and knows how important it is to me, I hope I will never get caught in that dilemma!
The idea of making more compilations and playing those instead has worked for me as well. After you get so many albums, it's tough to listen to each of them fully anyway!
And she did introduce me to the music of Dead Can Dance, Cocteau Twins, and Jeff Buckley, so the relationship has been good in terms of a music exchange.
posted 08-07-2001 10:03 AM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Oscar® Winner

In fact, one year my wife got a $200.00 Christmas bonus and gave it to me to buy soundtracks. How awesome is that. Isn't love grand.
I of course did get some which she would like and listen to.[Message edited by SEBULBA on 08-07-2001]
posted 08-07-2001 10:28 AM PT (US) 
Lou Goldberg

Oscar® Winner

Can't speak for myself, not married. The two live-in girlfriends I had didn't seem to mind. Although, like above, one couldn't get into Philip Glass. The other became a bigger Morricone fan than I am! I'm sure she's still out there collecting somewhere.There was one girlfriend I didn't live with who thought film music was "cool" as we started to go out together and said "I'm not into that stuff" as things broke down between us.
A married friend of mine who has kids moved his collection of CDs and LPs down into his basement so the kids couldn't mess with them, but also I think so he could get away from everyone and listen to music. He says he can't go there too often though because duty calls. I don't think he ever told me whether his wife likes what he plays or not. But, like me, he's into a great deal of different sounds--jazz, rock, classical, opera, etc.--that I'm sure he has something to play that she'll like.
I guess the worst stories are ones like the guy who owned a huge collection of soundtracks and his fiancee told him, the LPs go or I do, and he actually dumped the collection!
I could always work around someone's schedule, but, never dump the scores. As Gershwin said, a woman is a sometime thing, but Hugo Friedhofer, on the other hand, is forever.
posted 08-09-2001 09:22 PM PT (US) 
Lou Goldberg

Oscar® Winner

Cine-sin's attached?! Lou hangs his head low....
posted 08-09-2001 09:26 PM PT (US) 
JJH

Oscar® Winner

I'm currently unattached, but my last girlfriend couldn't understand my film music, so I had to put up with hers.she didn't last long.
NP -- Gormenghast, RRB
posted 08-09-2001 09:47 PM PT (US) 
SBD
Oscar® Winner

Congrats to all the "attached" collectors here. TV's Frank, here's a suggestion: Have you considered playing "Little Women"?
posted 08-10-2001 06:23 AM PT (US) 
Widescreen
Oscar® Winner

Here's irony for you: this thread comes two weeks for me to the day of proposing and getting engaged to my now fiancee, plus I'm moving in this weekend. She's known of my deep love for this music and how far it goes back for me- what helps for me is that she's got a degree in Music Education and teaches private flute lessons. She is very much appreciative to listen to all music, especially film music, and it'll be interesting when I come home from the CD store with the scores for Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back, The Musketeer, and Ghosts of Mars. I think she'll be supportive of my purchases because I'm largely judicious of what I buy. I may not get all of the last three I listed, it assumes I may have seen the movie and decided the score isn't worth it. (Oh, who am I kidding, I'll get the score for Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back no matter what!) Point being when buying these things, I think our significant others want to know is this more important to us than buying something important for sustaining household and life. That's when the buying habits change. Difference is for me, I budget well and recycle any money I get from CD's I sell off that I don't care about back into getting CDs I know I'll keep for more than two years minimum.It's strange my semantics, but then again that's par for course.
posted 08-10-2001 06:55 AM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

Thanks for the suggestion, SBD, I will track it down! She did sorta like parts of OSCAR&LUCINDA, which I know is somehwat similar, so that bodes well.
And congrats to Widescreen! Good luck on the upcoming move and I wish you and your fiance well for the future. I hope she remains understanding of the music! I think sometimes when I pick up an odd score title that my fiance my finally admit, "This is just too far out there for me", yet she always takes seriously whatever I'm really interested in (unless it's Thomas Newman!).
posted 08-10-2001 08:46 AM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Oscar® Winner

I would kind of hope that if someone is getting married and really has a passion for film music, that the other would take it seriously and be understanding. After all, if you're getting married and in love, that's part of what it's about, right? Fortunately I've been very lucky with my wife, and it sounds as if most of the others have been pretty lucky too.
posted 08-10-2001 09:49 AM PT (US) 
sabbey

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by Lou Goldberg:
I guess the worst stories are ones like the guy who owned a huge collection of soundtracks and his fiancee told him, the LPs go or I do, and he actually dumped the collection!I don't know what's more sad, giving up one's collection to be with a loved one, or the fact there are people who would have chosen the collection instead!

Oh well, I am not attached. And from the looks of it, I will be for quite awhile to come. If the story above is true, I am not so worried anymore!

Regards,
Sean Robert Abbeyposted 08-10-2001 03:18 PM PT (US) 
Lou Goldberg

Oscar® Winner

Sabbey--I think the point is that if someone makes that kind of request of you, they don't really love you or will be too demanding to be compatible with. So really, it's not sad that someone picks the collection over the lover because chances are down the road that the married guy who gave up his collection will be divorced AND have no records.
posted 08-11-2001 04:08 AM PT (US) 
Ken S

Oscar® Winner

Lou, I'm with you on that one....Love may drift away but music is forever...

posted 08-11-2001 04:18 AM PT (US) 
Mark Olivarez

Oscar® Winner

To hell with em, I play what I want when I want!!!!!
Seriously, my first attempt at marriage met with mixed results when it came to soundtracks. She was mostly a country & western fan with a little classical mixed in. She loved Batman but didn't like Aliens because it just sounded like "noise" to her. At that time CDs were just beginning to hit the market and my finances were required elswhere so my collection was mostly Williams.The last two relationships, one which is still current, have met with better results. The first one was a Kiss and metal fanatic. she had the the score to Titanic and thought that was all that. We had some interesting soundtrack discussions but I never played any for her cause we lived an hour apart our time together was scarce. My current girlfriend is about 8 1/2 years younger than me (I'm 33)so we have a slight generation gap when it comes to music. She prefers rap, ugh. Give me old school Run-DMC and Doug E Fresh any day, anyhow luckily she was in the band in school and has played some movie themes. She loves the score to A.I. I've been slowly feeding her info and scores to get her adjusted.
Funny thing was she thought the theme from ST: The Next Generation was specifically composed for the TV show since they played it that way in high school. I popped in ST:TMP to show her the light. 
posted 08-11-2001 08:55 AM PT (US) 
cine-sin

Oscar® Winner

A friend of mine used to go with a girl who absolutely forbade him to listen to his idol (Stevie Nicks). As such, he never listened to her for years. Thankfully, he saw the light and gave her the marching orders she deserved. He now has a partner who fully supports his musical tastes. In fact, they both travelled from Australia to the US to see some of the concerts from her current tour.Now its one thing to get your partner to put the toilet seat down but a completely different ball game when putting a halt to ones artistic tastes. You don't have to like it only accept it.
Regards,
Rochelleposted 08-11-2001 09:30 AM PT (US) 
sabbey

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by Lou Goldberg:
Sabbey--I think the point is that if someone makes that kind of request of you, they don't really love you or will be too demanding to be compatible with. So really, it's not sad that someone picks the collection over the lover because chances are down the road that the married guy who gave up his collection will be divorced AND have no records.I don't know! There are certain things even CD/Record's can't do, that a loved might just excel at. Let's just leave it at that!

Seriously though...

Of course! Just me adding what I thought was a bit of humor! Really, I can't understand how anyone could make such a request. I'd think, if this was such a problem, they would have made mention of it long before that point.

Regards,
Sean Robert Abbeyposted 08-11-2001 02:33 PM PT (US) 
Lou Goldberg

Oscar® Winner

I have a very tiny penis so after I play the CD I can fit my penis in the hole and have sex with it too. Women aren't too interested in me for obvious reasons......Certainly human relationships have a potential for happiness that music and movies can't provide, but anyone making this kind of request is more interested in their happiness at your expense than in providing you happiness. Some compromise is necessary in relationships, but better to jack the boy alone and wait than give up your collection in trade for the quick skin.
posted 08-12-2001 08:03 PM PT (US) 
sabbey

Oscar® Winner

Having sex with a CD? Ehhh! That is nasty, I was talking about a massage!

Really though! I agree with all of what you say (except the part about having a tiny penis, I have no idea how that would be.)
I think all of us have the ability to be selfish at times in our lives, I guess it counts on just how much. Oh well, I myself have been known to be at times. But, in a circumstance such as this?! It would certainly have pissed me off. Love is sometimes fickle, at other times great. I just hope the bitchiness doesn't rear it's ugly face too often. 
Regards,
Sean Robert Abbey[Message edited by sabbey on 08-12-2001]
posted 08-12-2001 10:56 PM PT (US) 
Richard

Oscar® Winner

I don't have anything constructive to add to this thread except I noticed someone mentioning Phillip Glass. Which reminds me of a joke...Knock knock.
who's there?
Knock knock.
who's there?
Knock knock.
who's there?
Knock knock.
who's there?Oh, it's just Phillip Glass.

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!posted 08-13-2001 01:37 PM PT (US) 
Lancelot

Oscar® Winner

I'm wondering if a "Film Music and Singles Board" is in order....or if it's just redundant...?
posted 08-13-2001 02:29 PM PT (US) 
TV's Frank

Oscar® Winner

Hah! Love that Glass joke!
And a Film Music&Singles board would probably be a nice idea - if thsi hobby wasn't 95% male!
I kinda like that my fiance was not into film music much when I met her, it gave us more to share about ourselves. I relish any reason to show off my "collection"!
posted 08-13-2001 02:47 PM PT (US) 
Lancelot

Oscar® Winner

Size Matters.
posted 08-13-2001 04:00 PM PT (US) 
Mark Olivarez

Oscar® Winner

Of course it does.
posted 08-13-2001 04:07 PM PT (US) 
cine-sin

Oscar® Winner

post-scriptumHaving said my partner supports my score listening habits - he recently declared how much he hates 'The Ludlows' from 'Legends of the Fall'. So much in fact, he asked me to stop playing it.
His reason? He says its too depressing and should be called 'Suicidals about to Fall'
Regards,
Rochelleposted 10-03-2001 06:31 AM PT (US) 
Lancelot

Oscar® Winner

Don'tcha hate how people misread the presence of emotion for depression?
posted 10-03-2001 06:42 AM PT (US) 
John C Winfrey

Oscar® Winner

Yes, Rochelle, that Legends of the Fall is a particularly boring tear-jerker to me. My daughter likes that film though. To each his own. One thing though, I heard that theme too many times in the film. John.
posted 10-04-2001 07:45 PM PT (US) 
cine-sin

Oscar® Winner

Lancelot - I don't understand it but as John said 'each to their own'.John - I don't find it boring or depressing at all. I actually prefer music with sorrowful/meloncholic tones but it doesn't get me down. I find it quite beautiful.
Regards,
Rochelle
NP: Germinalposted 10-06-2001 07:14 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
