-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Latest Poll on moviemusic.com!
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Latest Poll on moviemusic.com!

Kris

Oscar® Winner

Seems a lot of non score fans take part of the poll. 64% voted in favour of "Songs in the movie"... or are a lot of you kidding?
posted 05-08-2001 06:52 AM PT (US) 
Pete M

Oscar® Winner

I know! I was just thinking about posting an identical thread. Good grief, well shocked, so I was. Still, there hadn't actually been all that many replies before. I'm not sure how it's doing now.Grrrrr. Songs. Unless they's good ones. And preferably on a seperate CD to the score (which should also be on a CD).

posted 05-08-2001 06:54 AM PT (US) 
SBD
Oscar® Winner

What I wanna know is this: What kind of FREAK voted for songs from the movie?! (And if this is a joke, you people, who cast that vote, suck at joke telling.)[Message edited by SBD on 05-08-2001]
posted 05-08-2001 07:28 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

I didn't vote at all (there's no point "original score, with original songs and music cut from the film if possible"), but the results are frightening indeed.NP: Antonín Dvorák: Slavonic Dances (Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks, Rafael Kubelik)
posted 05-08-2001 08:16 AM PT (US) 
jonathan_little
Oscar® Winner

Lame.
posted 05-08-2001 11:04 AM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

HAHAHAHAHA. Oh man, that really says something now, doesn't it? Come on guys, being in the minority isn't all that bad... not everyone can be enlightened.
posted 05-08-2001 11:43 AM PT (US) 
wistiti

Oscar® Winner

Isn't this because many people who visit MM don't care about the board?And that most soundtrack buyers couldn't care less about score releases?
The most amazing part is that some 34% of people actually answered that they prefer scores.
If you were to take a random sample on a busy street, I'm ready to bet that the number of people who prefer score soundtracks would be much lower than 34%.
And if you think people who like song soundtracks are freaks and weirdos, imagine what they think of us.
(Never has it even crossed their minds that the way one purchases Mozart CDs, one can also purchase Goldsmith albums.)I mean, seriously, what's the point of buying instrumental film music? Isn't it just noise? Come on, you people can't seriously consider not only buying that stuff, but actually following the careers of given composers, and commenting on their latest compositions.
Can each one of you score liking losers please get a life?posted 05-08-2001 07:10 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by wistiti:
Isn't this because many people who visit MM don't care about the board?And that most soundtrack buyers couldn't care less about score releases?
But why do people who just care for the songs, not for the scores, visit film music websites?

NP: Jean Sibelius: Symphony #1 (New York Philharmonic, Leonard Bernstein)
posted 05-08-2001 07:39 PM PT (US) 
sabbey

Oscar® Winner

Out of the choices, I voted for score only. Though, that goes without saying!
However, this poll was flawed IMO. There were select choices not included that should have been. Such as, "best representation of film's soundtrack", or "score only, except when there are songs actually with the film"

Regards,
Sean Robert Abbeyposted 05-08-2001 07:52 PM PT (US) 
El Cid
Oscar® Winner

The choices should have been:(1) Songs from the movie
(2) Songs not from the movie
(3) Mix of songs from the movie and not from the movie
(4) Anything with a good beatMore seriously, one ought to distinguish between original songs and random licensed crap. It's not *always* wrong for a song to be on a soundtrack...songs definitely belong on the Fiddler on the Roof soundtrack, for example. But 99% of the time, no...
posted 05-08-2001 11:49 PM PT (US) 
Probable

Oscar® Winner

People keep pointing out that most MM fans don't visit the message boards. I think that there's a reason for that, especially given the poll results. Thnk about it: Film scores are a specific genre that can be discussed, analyzed, and evaluated by a discreet group. Songs used in films are a hodgepodge of rock, pop, classic love songs, and countless other types. What would you discuss? The people who buy these are the same as the people who buy 'mix' CDs. Who discusses 'mix' CDs? There's no "80sCompilationCDFan.com," nor should there be.Am I making any sense?
More to the point, do I ever? I'm trying, anyway, in this case.posted 05-11-2001 05:21 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little
Oscar® Winner

I was trying to figure out "what the hell were they thinking" regarding this latest poll, so I sampled some of the reviews for popular song albums here at MovieMusic.com:quote:
Coyote Ugly:
5 stars - comments made by a soundtrack fan on 8/17/2000
favorite track: 9
This was a great soundtrack to go with a great movie. It's just like me! Moving from a small town to a big city to hitting big in the music industry. Now all i have to do is become a coyote. WA OWWW....Now all I have to do is become a coyote... Yeah. As the saying in the film music world goes, "Have you taken your meds lately?"
quote:
Save the Last Dance:
5 stars - comments made by a soundtrack fan on 1/29/2001
favorite track: 4
There aren't very many romantic songs on here, but the ones that are hit hard!! I do appreciate all the songs that don't have to cuss every other word, and that's cool. I think this is a great soundtrack... there are not many you can say that about!!Ah yes, a "great, hard-hitting" soundtrack. Those are pretty rare these days. I just wish they had more cuss words.
quote:
Notting Hill:
comments made by a soundtrack fan on 4/10/2001
favorite track: 8
This soundtrack portrays the emotions of the movie exactly in 13 songs. It makes me want to fall in love every time I put it on my cd player.Ah yes, there is nothing like a soundtrack song album to make you fall in love... (fall in love with what? My CD player provides great music, but...)
NP: The Omega Man -- WHERE'S THE DAMN SONGS?
posted 05-11-2001 06:33 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

Alright, you guys. You ready for an experiment? Let's talk about how we can offer the same poll, but get different results....I am going to recast this poll, but switch the order of the choices (the first will go last), and re-word the choices a bit.
There may be a comparatively interesting outcome after this little experiment. What do you say?
[Message edited by PeterK on 05-15-2001]
posted 05-15-2001 04:03 PM PT (US) 
Scorro
Oscar® Winner

Sure, and include some of El Cid's recommendations in there.
posted 05-15-2001 04:09 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

Ok, let the expirement begin. For the record, here's how the last poll ended:What do you like on your movie soundtracks?
Songs from the movie 69%
Original score music only 19%
Mix of songs and score 4%
Music not heard in the film 6%
total votes: 1612posted 05-18-2001 10:17 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Looks quite different now, with "Score only" leading (though I picked "Songs & score, I want all the music", because sometimes (!) the songs ARE an integral part of the score).Now what does this mean? Do people just pick the first option in a poll without reading it? Or is the poll software faulty? Reminds me of that "Favourite Horner score" thread which failed at the beginning because several of us voted for one score, only to see their vote had ended up being given to another one. Hmm.

NP: Jean Sibelius: Symphony #2 (Philharmonia Orchestra, Jean Sibelius)
posted 05-18-2001 03:13 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little
Oscar® Winner

Some university or government agency should spend thousands to find out what the deal is!
posted 05-18-2001 07:31 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

The poll was only faulty for those 30-minutes I had it rigged to see how fast you guys would respond.... Darn quick, as I recall!It's long been known by those who study surfing habits that people usually click on the first thing they see. With polls, you'd think the outcome would be different, but it appears some of the old thinking/doing is still happening. After more votes have been cast, we'll see if more or less people are considering the choices or not.
posted 05-18-2001 10:40 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Would it perhaps be possible to change the poll script so that it shuffles the options everytime someone loads a page? That would cause the "blind votes" to be more or less equally distributed among the possible choices.NP: Captain Blood (Erich Wolfgang Korngold)
posted 05-19-2001 06:28 AM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

Ha! That's a neat idea. I would consider it if, in the end, the voting was completely fumbled up. After 1,000 votes have been cast, we'll see if things are similar or bushwhacked when compared with the previous poll.
posted 05-19-2001 10:09 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Hm, things have changed: The "songs" option is now in the lead again. What people are visiting MM.com??NP: The Blue Max (Jerry Goldsmith)
posted 05-19-2001 04:43 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

There are two crowds: heavy repeat visitors and transient visitors (those who come back maybe once a month, or never again). There are only a few hundred heavy repeat users, and an untold number of transient visitors. Most of the repeat visitors vote within a few days of the new poll, while transients regularly stream in the votes. This should help explain why results start one way, and sometimes drift differently over time.
posted 05-19-2001 04:49 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Sure, but what confuses
me is that I had always been assuming that the people visiting this site at all are mostly film SCORE fans. I mean, why would anyone else come here?NP: Sabrina (John Williams)
posted 05-19-2001 05:38 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little
Oscar® Winner

I wonder if the people in Florida actually read their ballots?
posted 05-19-2001 10:46 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

Now's the time to compare results, as we close in on a similar number of votes for each of these.What do you want on your movie soundtracks?
Score music only 31%
Songs not in the movie 9%
Songs and score 15%
Songs in the movie 40%
A good beat will do 2%
1565 total votes.
The results are noticeably different.... interesting experiment, or not?posted 05-31-2001 03:37 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
