-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
James Horner Question
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: James Horner Question

Vladimir
Oscar® Winner

I wanted to know what James Horner CD's should i get that i don't already have. I don't have many but here is what i have so farDeep Impact
Bravehart
Perfect Storm
Titanic
Titanic Vol 2
Mask of ZoroThanks for any opinions
matt
posted 02-01-2001 12:57 PM PT (US) 
Widescreen
Oscar® Winner

That's stuff is nothing compared to the Cd's of his you should really get:Star Trek II
Star Trek III
Krull
Aliens
Willow
The Rocketeer
The Pelican Briefposted 02-01-2001 01:19 PM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Oscar® Winner

Vlad, of the ones you mention, I have:Braveheart: sheer brilliance, covers a lot of ground.
Mask Of Zorro: pretty good, lively too.
Perfect Storm: quite intensely dramatic, but a bit exhausting.
Titanic: kind of ordinary, but maybe we're all just tired of Titanic per se.
If you like Horner at his overbearing best (and I generally do), you'll probably like everything you listed (none of his electronic late 80s ramblings!) And I imagine that if you don't like Horner, then you wouldn't have posted to start with!
posted 02-01-2001 01:54 PM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Oscar® Winner

Forgive me everyone whilst I shoot myself. NINCOMPOOP! See Widescreen's post: HE understood your question (I think).
posted 02-01-2001 01:56 PM PT (US) 
Rang
Oscar® Winner

* FIELD OF DREAMS
* THE MAN WITHOUT A FACE
* THE LAND BEFORE TIMEAll are very good scores.
GLORY is also a good one to consider.
posted 02-01-2001 01:57 PM PT (US) 
Stephen Lister

Oscar® Winner

Sneakers, Legends of the Fall and Gorky Park should be on any Horner fan's must-have list.
posted 02-01-2001 02:16 PM PT (US) 
Timmer

Oscar® Winner

The 2 'must have's' are...
KRULL 2 CD set, still one of the most exciting film scores of all time.Brainstorm....would you believe Silvestri ripped this off for The Abyss
I also really like 'if you can still find it' In The Name Of The Rose...an electronic score for medieval monks?....my God it works!

posted 02-01-2001 02:17 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Rose is electronic? It's been so long since I've watched the film. Anyway, some time ago I noticed a bit of background music during a radio broadcast that sounded familiar, and after about a minute (when the music was long over
) I realized it was Rose.Willow, despite a MAJOR rip-off from Schumann's 3rd Symphony (come on, you can't deny this), is a wonderful score. I just wish it wouldn't annoy me anytime the Schumann stuff appears. But the rest is awesome. Trek 2, Krull and Brainstorm are very good, but Willow is my favourite.
I still haven't played Perfect Storm often enough to have an opinion.
Sneakers works very well in the (wonderful) film, and I've been meaning to get the CD for years - but I still don't have it.
NP: Ralph Vaughan Williams: A Sea Symphony (London Philharmonic Orchestra, Sir Adrian Boult)
posted 02-01-2001 03:15 PM PT (US) 
David OC

Oscar® Nominee

Any true Horner fan could not live without the following great scores -
Coccoon, The Rocketeer, Courage Under Fire(Horner reused the Al Bathra action music, almost note for note, on Titanic a year later)
and two other gems that are rarely mentioned -
Searching for Bobby Fischer
and The Spitfire Grill (the second half of the CD is especially great)
posted 02-03-2001 03:20 AM PT (US) 
Mark Olivarez

Oscar® Winner

I would suggest these Horner Scores:Brainstorm
Cocoon
Star Trek II
Krull
The Land Before Time
Aliens
Willow
GloryI would also suggest Mighty Joe Young for the Windsong as his Highness has pointed out many times.
posted 02-03-2001 07:41 AM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

H'ness, Mark! H'ness!!!!!Marian: THE NAME OF THE ROSE is almost entirely electronic; I've never been sure if the boy-choral sound is sampled or not. I found it a bizarre approach to the film, but not inappropriate, although the resulting album is somewhat dull. Horner fought hard to get that movie and use that approach, back when he was still relatively experimental. (It didn't hurt that synth scores were also very trendy at the time.)
SNEAKERS is probably Horner's best work in the 1990s, although I have a personal sneaking fondness for ONCE AROUND as well. BRAVEHEART, APOLLO 13 and TITANIC are somewhat guilty pleasures. ZORRO has its moments. I still think DEEP IMPACT and PERFECT STORM are dreadful, and anyone who likes that side of Horner probably will be thrilled to hear his more vibrant earlier work -- the bulk of which was written in the 1980s.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! KRULL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and maybe I like STAR TREK 3 more than a lot of people do, self-derivative as it is. Still, I remember seeing STAR TREK 2 the first time and being blown away by the music, wondering who the hell this Horner character was, and scampering away (in these pre-internet days) to the film section of bookstores to look him up in the indexes. Still a film music neophyte then, I wondered if he was some legend I had so far managed to overlook. (I had yet to see WOLFEN or HUMANOIDS FROM THE DEEP, both of which are also persuasively written.)
NP: THE STRIPPER (Jerry Goldsmith, FSM release that came in the mail today -- MUCH better sound than the bootleg, I'm happy to report, and cues from something called NICK QUARRY to boot)
posted 02-03-2001 11:27 AM PT (US) 
Mark Olivarez

Oscar® Winner

D'oh!!!!! Sorry H'ness.
posted 02-03-2001 11:30 AM PT (US) 
lars b

Oscar® Winner

Star Trek 2 : Wrath of Khaaaaaaan.
Nothing as inspired has come from Horner since then.
posted 02-05-2001 07:20 AM PT (US) 
Andy Lindahl

Oscar® Winner

What the... Why haven't you guys mentioned THE SPITFIRE GRILL as well?! Great score. Heck, amazing score!
posted 02-05-2001 01:10 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

I agree with Andy. Spitfire is among one of my favorite Horner scores.Jeron
posted 02-05-2001 01:49 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
