-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Shadows of the Empire... Book, McNeely's Programmatic Score, then the Game...
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Shadows of the Empire... Book, McNeely's Programmatic Score, then the Game...

Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Kyp and I are currently on the phone... in a debate as to what order they all came out.I say this:
1)Book
2)Score
3)GameKyp says:
1)Game
2)Book
3)ScoreTo me, and correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Steve Perry wrote this great book from a video game which hardly does it justice. The book came out first, then McNeely's music, based on the book. Then Nintendo and LucasArts released a game loosely based on Perry's story, conveniently using snippets of McNeely's score throughout. I'm pretty sure I'm right about this... Though (of course) Kyp thinks he's dead on the money. Both of us can't be right. Anyone wanna clear this up? Like I said... I'm pretty sure I've got my facts straight.
Jeron
[Message edited by Jeron on 10-31-2000]
posted 10-31-2000 03:49 PM PT (US) 
Crono/Kyp

Oscar® Winner

You would. But It's all in good fun.
--Kyppy
Writer/Editor[Message edited by Crono/Kyp on 10-31-2000]
posted 10-31-2000 03:51 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Yeah and I still wanna know who's right and who's wrong.
hehe
posted 10-31-2000 03:55 PM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Oscar® Winner

Well, I don't know for sure myself, but I tend to remember it as Jeron does. But again, I can't be positive.
posted 10-31-2000 05:39 PM PT (US) 
Justin

Oscar® Winner

Jeron is right. It was the book, the score and then the game! I remember seeing the book and then the score so I asked if the score was based on the book and the guy behind the counter had no clue. He then went on to say a game would be coming out soon so it may be for that.
posted 10-31-2000 06:03 PM PT (US) 
JJH

Oscar® Winner

{flips a coin...lands on it's side..}well, apparently no one is right.
it's game
score
book
posted 10-31-2000 06:44 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

And I still find it strange that the "score" is marketed as a film score. "Tone poem" would be much more correct.NP: Alien complete (Jerry Goldsmith)
posted 10-31-2000 06:49 PM PT (US) 
Shaun Rutherford

Oscar® Winner

First came Adam & Eve.Shaun
posted 10-31-2000 08:36 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Shaun? Thanks for that tip there buddy. And Marian, I think you're right on the dot.[Message edited by Jeron on 10-31-2000]
posted 10-31-2000 09:08 PM PT (US) 
MWRuger

Oscar® Winner

Actually, they were probably all done at the same time. I was working for a distributor and we listed them in the same month along with a buttload of other SOTE merchandise. This was part of a Star Wars marketing blitz!
posted 10-31-2000 09:13 PM PT (US) 
Aaron Collins

Oscar® Winner

Well, everyone seems to always leave out the made-for-TV movie, Shadows of the Empire.And lets not forget the prequel: "The Empire is hidden in Shadows"
The correct order is:
*Prequel
*TV movie
*Book
*Score
*and game
I hope my info helps!Aaron
posted 10-31-2000 11:36 PM PT (US) 
MWRuger

Oscar® Winner

Aaron, I could find no listing for a TV movie or a prequel on IMDB. Did you actually see the TV movie?
posted 11-01-2000 09:54 AM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

HAHAHA. Ruger, come on man. Aaron is pulling your leg. That post is drenched in sarcasm. I guess it's hard to know unless you really know Aaron Collins and the way his mind works (I'm only semi-knowledgeable). That's my buddy.
posted 11-01-2000 02:01 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

aaron is not exactly right....he forgot about the ewok adventure movire
posted 11-02-2000 10:01 AM PT (US) 
Aaron Collins

Oscar® Winner

Ya, sorry Ruger. I was just being sarcastic and thought what a goofy post this was.Jeron, how does my mind work? I would like to know buddy.
Thanks,
Aaronposted 11-02-2000 12:11 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

I told you, I'm only semi-knowledgable. If you hadn't stopped going to your appointments at that research facility (forgot the name of it), perhaps we'd have more information.
posted 11-02-2000 01:16 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Oh... and I was thinking Marian. Technically, can we really call it a tone poem? I thought a symphonic poem and a tone poem were both one movement pieces. McNeely refers to his composition as being a multi-movement work.
posted 11-02-2000 01:18 PM PT (US) 
Racerprose

Oscar® Winner

I should know this....
Game
Score
Book
Then Series of books afterwards.-Racerprose
posted 11-02-2000 03:00 PM PT (US) 
sean

Oscar® Winner

nope, it's -book
score
gameThe book was written, John Williams was asked to score (but couldn't cause of scheduling problems) and he recommended Joe McNeely. So, McNeely scored it and Williams was unhappy with it (I wouldn't blame him!). And so then, a game was made....you may also notice that the game uses music from McNeely's as well as Williams' score for Empire Strikes Back.... again - book, score, game :P
NP: Crimson Tide - Hans Zimmer - *****/*****
[Message edited by sean on 11-02-2000]
posted 11-02-2000 03:29 PM PT (US) 
Racerprose

Oscar® Winner

Sorry, but you are incorrect. To begin a score you HAVE to have a project/idea (i.e Shadows of the Empire). LucasArts wanted to make a Star Wars game that involved 3D graphics (because back when the game came out 3D graphics were IN). Then during the game development it was decided that Joel McNeely score the game because Williams did not want to. Then afterwards the game was so popular a book was written about it.And thats the story....

-Racerprose
posted 11-02-2000 03:46 PM PT (US) 
AaronR1074

Oscar® Winner

I seem to recall this:The Phantom Menace
A New Hope
The Empire Strikes Back
Shadows of the Empire
Return of the Jedi
Heir to the Empire
Dark Force Rising
The Last Command
Truce at Bakura
Courtship of Princess Leia
The Crystal Star
Children of the Jedi
Darksaber <========Best book of the series!!!After the Shadows novel was released, both the game, score, and comic books were released simultaneously. The famous Kenner figures were released afterwards.
PS: I ended the novels at Darksaber because the whole thing went downhill from there. Plus I hated the paperbacks.

posted 11-02-2000 05:08 PM PT (US) 
Racerprose

Oscar® Winner

Why doesen't some contact LucasArts directly? Then it will end this dispute.
-Racerprose
posted 11-02-2000 05:46 PM PT (US) 
charben
Oscar® Winner

AaronR1074, you might want to read Zahn's two "sequels" to the Thrawn trilogy, "Spectre of the Past" and "Vision of the Future." They both provide a fitting end to Bantam's Star Wars series. The X-Wing novels by Aaron Allston & Michael Stackpole are also very entertaining, especially if you are a computer gamer and have played the X-Wing flight sims from LucasArts.Chris Harben
Atlantic Beach, FLposted 11-02-2000 05:57 PM PT (US) 
Obi Jok Kenobi

Oscar® Winner

I'm sure it was this:Book, Score and Game simultaneously.
There was a big thing about how good the book was and it turned out to be so popular the game and score was released at the same time, followed by the action figures and comics!
Well, that's how it was here in Australia, so I imagine it would have been the same anywhere else.
posted 11-02-2000 06:00 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Jeron, I always thought "symphonic poem" and "tone poem" (I suppose both are different names for the same thing) don't have a strict musical structure? I believe Smetana's Ma Vlast is a tone poem, yet it has 6 movements (not only the famous The Moldau (is it "Moldau" in English?))NP: Ludwig van Beethoven: Symphony #9 (Vienna Philharmonic, Leonard Bernstein)
posted 11-03-2000 03:29 AM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Hmm... yeah. I'll find out, Marian.And Racerprose, I distinctively remember buying the score and book BEFORE the game was released. Then Nintendo and LucasArts announced the game - and I was ecstatic! If you'll read in the liner notes of the score, nowhere does Robert Townson mention the game. He says that the music was written for the book.
Jeron
posted 11-03-2000 08:29 AM PT (US) 
AaronR1074

Oscar® Winner

Charben,
I'll definately consider that, since I loved Zahn's first 3...but at the moment I'm trying to polish off the Robert Jordan novels before his new one comes out...plus I've got a new Terry Goodkind hardcover to buy as well.Mabye after xmas I'll go back to my Star Wars roots. I was, after all, a proud member of the Star Wars fanclub for a couple years prior to the release of the Special Editions to the theatres
posted 11-03-2000 07:04 PM PT (US) 
Maestro Sartori

Oscar® Winner

Okay Guys,Not that I'm the foremost Star Wars expert in these boards, but I do have every available paperback in the shole series, bought when each came out, but I also was in the stores as each HARD cover was released.
Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire, by Steve Perry, was a huge media blitz (and gamble) by Lucasfilm, Ltd. and Bantam Books.
The whole concept was to have a new novel come out about DARTH VADER, Luke, Leia and the others, during the original trilogy. If you remember, at this point, every book took place afterward, from 1991 through April 1996, when Shadows was released.
Steve was given the concept and the freedom to write and invent new characters, provided he didn't change what we knew about Return of the Jedi.
AT THE SAME TIME, Joel McNeely, in a special licensed agreement with Varese Sarabande, (note that McNeely almost is entirely partial to Varese releases), was given the task of creating new music INSPIRED by the story. In his insert notes, Robert Townsend tells us that the music isn't supposed to be listened to along with reading the book, (thereby proving that it was released at the same time as the book), but as an audio experience of the imagery created by Perry.
AT THE SAME TIME, the video game was created, then released. I believe it hit both Nintendo and Play Station, though that may need correction from you video game enthusiasts.
It was a broadband media event, in written form, CD, and video games, designed to hit every entertainment interest out there, with the exception of TV and movies.
Hope that clears it up. The all came out together.
posted 11-10-2000 12:36 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by Maestro Sartori:
AT THE SAME TIME, the video game was created, then released. I believe it hit both Nintendo and Play Station, though that may need correction from you video game enthusiasts.It was also release for Windows PCs. I always wanted to have it, but only got the demo version.
NP: Anton Bruckner: Symphony #2 (National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland, Georg Tintnet)
posted 11-10-2000 04:41 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
