-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Star Trek: TMP DVD
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Star Trek: TMP DVD

Aaron R. Brown

Oscar® Winner

Star Trek: TMP is coming to DVD next year. It will have some more new scenes. It will also be rated PG instead of G like the original because of the changes.I wonder if there will be anymore Goldsmith score for these scenes. If there is, hardly anyone has heard it. The Columbia/Legacy sountrack missed alot of music that was in the original release. I wanted the cue "Captain's Log". There are couple of others too that I can't think of right now!
posted 10-03-2000 10:51 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Considering how much this movie is carried by it's score, it would be a perfect candidate for an iso score. But I can't see it happen.NP: Sergei Prokofiev: Ivan the Terrible (Saint Louis Symphony Orchestra & Chorus, Leonard Slatkin)
posted 10-03-2000 04:23 PM PT (US) 
Wedge

Oscar® Winner

Been listening to that a lot, haven't you Marian! I warned you ...As for Star Trek on DVD, those idiots at Paramount had loads of extras for the other films -- specials, scores, deleted scenes, production artwork, interviews ... and they blew it. Especially with such a rabid fan base ready to lap it all up. Let's hope they get TMP right!
posted 10-03-2000 04:39 PM PT (US) 
Kevin
Oscar® Winner

Well, from what I've heard, Robert Wise is re-cutting the movie, because he wasn't happy with the final release.So we should get a really good treatment of the film.
Kevin
posted 10-03-2000 10:15 PM PT (US) 
samanthasmom
Oscar® Nominee

First off I love Jerry Goldsmiths score to Star Trek, But the movie is dull as dirt. Robert Wise who knows how to direct a sci-fi lost his way on this flic. It was way too slow and everyone looked stiff and bored. Way too much money went into the visual effects and not enough went into a script.Great idea, but the first Star Trek was not inkeeping with what Star Trek 2 provided, humor, freindship and caring. Star Trek, was cold as space. It needed a real villian, not Vger. A man made hunk of junk. It seemed to me at one point and time during the filming of this junk, the actors would of told Robert Wise, this is crap! We are bailing out!
The music Jerry Goldsmith is excellent, great fun, if you did not know any better you would not of known that it came from such a BAD film.The best quote from a review of Star Trek was from Time Magazine was When the slow Spaceships took off and moved slowly through space and when they finally got to their destination there was nothing to see!
Star Trek 2 should of been the First Star Trek. Thank you Nicholas Meyer.And Arbro, Do you not have the expanded version of Star Trek?
NP: Superman, expanded **** John Williams
posted 10-04-2000 07:19 AM PT (US) 
Greg Bryant

Oscar® Winner

quote:
A man made hunk of junk. It seemed to me at one point and time during the filming of this junk, the actors would of told Robert Wise, this is crap! We are bailing out!
This would not have happened. All the cast needed the work. Shatner was reduced to making "Kingdom of the Spiders" and living out of his camper. Nimoy was doing "In Search Of..."They were all having a hard time getting other work because of the usual Star Trek typecasting (which Patrick Stewart seems to have mercifully escaped). I suspect the cast would have acted in test patterns if that's all that Paramount had sent their way. Kind of sad that they needed to depend on Paramount that much.
[Message edited by Greg Bryant on 10-04-2000]
posted 10-04-2000 08:59 AM PT (US) 
samanthasmom
Oscar® Nominee

GregYou are right!!! Kingdom of Spiders, I think it had a better script than Star Trek.
Oh Well.But a excellent score.
posted 10-04-2000 12:29 PM PT (US) 
Dan Brecher

Oscar® Winner

While it was a shame Paramount treated the other movies with such little care, TMP is actually going to be an exception, and Paramount have stated they've not ruled out Special Ed's of ALL the other films in the future.I am due to see an advanced DVD screening at Paramount in LA this November. What title it is I am unsure of, but it could very well be ST: TMP I guess... Hope so!
Dan (UK)
posted 10-04-2000 01:00 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

Why, don't you all remember who scored KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS? He scored the same director's subsequent movie THE DARK as well.William Shatner received a Saturn Award nomination for Best Actor for KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS. I'd have voted him the award, all those damn tarantulas he had to be buried in throughout.
Immediately following STAR TREK V, and during the days when Cannon Films was pretending to be on top of the world, the studio announced KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS 2, which would both star AND be directed by STAR TREK V auteur Bill Shatner himself! I'm sorry they didn't go ahead with it ...
posted 10-04-2000 03:45 PM PT (US) 
James

Oscar® Winner

I LOVE KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS! It's a very enjoyable movie. But I'm not sure what you meant about the score, H'ness, unless you were joking. The film itself NEVER MENTIONS a score composer, only crediting whats-his-name with the songs. The IMDb shows Roger Kellaway for THE DARK, however. But I was under the impression that KINGDOM's score came completely from music libraries, as I'm sure I've heard the same music elsewhere.I haven't heard THE DARK, but either way KINGDOM's score was trivialized by Cardos's 1980 THE DAY TIME ENDED, which featured one of the BEST cues in Richard Band's whole career (a shame the sound quality-and the move itself-was so horrible).
To make this relevant to this discussion, it is interesting to point out (as the liner notes on Varese's LP for DAY explain) that THE DAY TIME ENDED was the 2nd score to use a combination of Analog and "new" digital recording techniques to create better sound (the sound quality of the LP is infinitely better than in the film). The 1st score to use this technique was (ta da!) STAR TREK: THE MOTION PICTURE!
Which brings me back on-topic. I'm looking forward to this release, even though I'm not fond of the film itself. My godfather once spent way too much of his time re-editing the film himself, giving it a faster pace and calling it the "improved" version, which, I must admit, it actually was. The pacing was far better and much more tolerable... except that he BUTCHERED Goldsmith's score (although he did seem to pay attention to the music during "The Enterprise"). If Wise is really re-cutting the film, it will be an interesting comparison for me. It will also be interesting to see what happens to Goldsmith's music as a consequence...
James
NP - The Day Time Ended (Richard Band) Side 2, #5: "Finale: The Intelligence/City of Light" (this is great stuff!).[Message edited by James on 10-04-2000]
posted 10-04-2000 08:56 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

Hmmm, Captain, I've done that kind of "re-editing" on a couple of films myself -- it surely is hell on the music. I'll be curious to see Wise's new cut as well. I'm tickled that your godfather couldn't bring himself to ruin "The Enterprise" ...
Director John "Bud" Cardos tracked both KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS and THE DARK with cues from the TWILIGHT ZONE episodes "Back There" and "The Invaders," composed by -- ta-daaa! -- that guy we saw in Detroit. I think KINGDOM has no original score. I haven't seen it in more than ten years, and might now be faster to notice other library cues Cardos might also have favored. Still, KINGDOM is tracked very well -- I particularly like the despairing movement from "Back There" that closes the movie, as we pull back and see everything wrapped in spiderwebs -- sort of one-upping the (planned, but unused) finale of THE BIRDS (the Golden Gate Bridge swathed in thousands of them).
THE DARK uses a lot of the same Goldsmith music (as does ALLIGATOR, released the following year, although that also incorporates an original score by Craig Hundley, himself a child actor on STAR TREK -- why he played your nephew, Captain. He also invented the Blaster Beam synthesizer, which Goldsmith used to such great effect in STAR TREK - TMP, and Hundley used the Blaster Beam in his ALLIGATOR score as well ... though a great deal of the final soundtrack relies on Goldsmith's "Invaders." You knew all this already, didn't you? Well, it's already typed.)
THE DARK also features some original music by Roger Kellaway, which is so stupidly written and falsely manipulative as to be fascinating. It's even worse than Kellaway's subsequent score to EVILSPEAK, which is the most blatant ripoff of the original OMEN that I've ever heard (Kellaway went so far as to lift the "Ave Satani" lyrics -- and simply mix up the words!) Kellaway basically scores THE DARK with silly hissing vocal effects, usually a solo voice whispering "DAAAAARK-NESSSSS! THE -- DAAAAAAARK!" and occasionally even "TEN-E-BRAE!" (Latin for, you guessed it, "darkness.")
Kellaway is best known for writing one of the themes for the TV show ALL IN THE FAMILY. How he drifted into horror scoring, I haven't a clue.
posted 10-05-2000 08:57 AM PT (US) 
James

Oscar® Winner

You told me a LOT I didn't know there, H Rocco. Always the fountain of information, you are.
You're right, the music in the end is particularly effective... until that horrible country song starts up.
Now my mind is racing with this question... would I still have said a Richard Band score (THE DAY TIME ENDED) was better than KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS if I had known that KINGDOM's music was actually by Goldsmith? I am a big Band fan, but still I wonder.... What's in a name?
James
posted 10-07-2000 09:59 AM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

I always find something a bit "off" about music when it's been tracked from another source ... I don't mean songs, I mean a piece of score lifted from one movie and grafted onto another. I don't mean I can automatically tell by listening to it, but sometimes I can ... e.g. THE HUNT FOR RED OCTOBER has one cue that sticks out like the proverbial sore thumb, Sean Connery talking with Sam Neill about their wives -- I believe Basil Poledouris scored this with a cue that we hear on the album, "Two Wives," but director John McTiernan favored his temp track -- an all-synthesizer cue from NO MAN'S LAND, ALSO by Poledouris! All I can guess is that McTiernan found Poledouris' approach too romantic (and I'll add that I find McTiernan one of the more tin-eared A-list directors presently working.)So why do I mention this? Because there IS something a bit "off" about the TWILIGHT ZONE music used in both of Cardos' movies, and it sounds wrong in ALLIGATOR as well. And I don't think this because I was familiar with the episodes in question. I saw ALLIGATOR well after KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS, and was downright puzzled by the use of the "Invaders" music -- naggingly familiar, where had I heard it before? And why does it clash so hard with the Blaster Beam stuff Hundley's writing? When I finally got around to seeing the original "Invaders," and hearing the Varese release of "Back There," I was not a little bit startled.
Hmm, if Shatner HAD made KINGDOM OF THE SPIDERS 2, would he have managed to talk Goldsmith into scoring it? And would Goldsmith have wittily interpolated bits of the old TWILIGHT ZONE stuff, just for fun? Silly little fantasy, but it amuses me somehow.
'ey Cap'n, I assume you've heard Richard Band's TROLL. I haven't, but would be curious to. No less a personage than Douglass Fake said in an interview that he played that one a GREAT deal (that was back when it was new, but I was interested, since I'd also heard it was mainly just another OMEN knockoff.)
NP: surprisingly competent, even ambitious, Silva Screen rerecording of one of Goldsmith's masterpieces, the Klingon Battle from that movie he did that this thread's about
posted 10-07-2000 02:07 PM PT (US) 
Wedge

Oscar® Winner

Hey, Rocco ... you're forgetting the most OBVIOUS incident of music tracked in from another movie, which would be Horner's "Aliens" at the end of Kamen's "Die Hard." Man did THAT come out of nowhere!
posted 10-07-2000 02:15 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by H Rocco:
THE HUNT FOR RED OCTOBER has one cue that sticks out like the proverbial sore thumb, Sean Connery talking with Sam Neill about their wives -- I believe Basil Poledouris scored this with a cue that we hear on the album, "Two Wives," but director John McTiernan favored his temp track -- an all-synthesizer cue from NO MAN'S LAND, ALSO by Poledouris!That's strange. I thought I could remember that there is NO music during that sequence...
NP: Logan's Run (Jerry Goldsmith)
posted 10-08-2000 06:55 AM PT (US) 
Aaron R. Brown

Oscar® Winner

Hi samanthasmom!I do have the expanded version of Star Trek: The Motion Picture. The sound quality of the score is one of the best I have heard from a film in 70's. Most scores of this age have some kind of hiss or shallow bass.
I wouldn't mind if Paramont Pictures released the dvd with a isolated track. There is hardly any dialog at the same time as the music so anyone could hear the music pretty well guess!
posted 10-08-2000 07:38 AM PT (US) 
Swashbuckler

Oscar® Winner

An isolated score track for Star Trek: The Motion Picture would be most welcome. There are several cues in the film still not really available from any source, although the lion's share can be found from somewhere. (Curiously, the "Decker Runs Into Ilia While She's On Her Smoke Break" cue doesn't seem to be available anywhere except under Nichelle Nichols' voice on the second disc of the 20th Anniversary set).On the DVD of Kentucky Fried Movie, John Landis, Jim Abrahams, David and Jerry Zucker mention that, while their film was pretty much scored with library music, the one exception is the "A Fistful of Yen" sequence, which was scored by the composer of Kingdom of the Spiders. I assume after what I have just read that this refers to the songwriter. The music for the sequence was so bad it's perfect.
Hey, some friends of mine really love to bring up another William Shatner movie called The Devil's Reign, which, as I understand it also has Ernest Borgnine, Tom Skerritt and many other actors of note. I have never seen this movie. How bad is it?
[Message edited by Swashbuckler on 10-08-2000]
posted 10-08-2000 08:08 AM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

Marian: I haven't seen the picture in a while, but that's what memory says (not that memory is always on speaking terms with me.)Wedge: Right before ALIENS' music appears in DIE HARD, I was EQUALLY jolted by the lovely music that accompanies the sight of the millions of shreds of paper floating to the ruined street ... a reflective moment from John Scott's MAN ON FIRE! I had never seen the film, but was a major John Scott fan by the time MAN ON FIRE came out, so picked up the CD. I was surprised to hear that music, but not displeased; I think I was rather irritated with the interpolation of ALIENS, though.
I think Kamen gave an interview to the effect that he told the producer "just buy the piece by John Scott!" Either he couldn't come up with anything that satisfied them as much melodically, or had no time to finish it, I don't recall.
NP: "The End" by The Doors
posted 10-08-2000 11:37 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
