The MovieMusic Store shopping cart   |  sign in
    SEARCH  
  • Home
  • Browse Store
    • New Soundtrack CDs
    • Top Sellers
    • Low Price New CDs
    • Used CDs
    • Soundtrack Compilations
    • Score Composers
    • Soundtrack Labels
    • Soundtracks by Year
    • ... detailed search page
  • Store Info
    • Happy Customers!
    • $1 Shipping
    • Accepted Payment Methods
    • Safe Shopping Guarantee
    • Shipping Rates & Policies
    • Our Privacy Policy
    • About Us
  • Help Center
    • My Account
    • How to Order
    • Search Tips
    • Return/Refund Policy
    • Cancelling Your Order
    • Contact the Store
  • The Lobby
  •   Message Boards
      Movie Soundtracks
      "What Motif's do you dislike in your soundtracks?"

    Archive of old forum. No more postings.

    Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.

    Author
    Topic:   "What Motif's do you dislike in your soundtracks?"

     Shivered_McTimber
     Click Here to Email Shivered_McTimber
     Oscar® Winner
     

    I was inspired to post this as I was listening to my "Zorro" soundtrack today.

    There is this annoying sound that is used musch too often in the soundtrack, nearly every track contains it. Those of you that have heard the soundtrack will know what I'm talking about when I say that it sounds like a dying Eagle.

    "Zorro leaps up heroically, catching a glipse of the sun in the background. There's that blasted Dying Eagle."

    "Zorro sees the evil mines of the bad guys, while the Dying Eagle cries from some unknown location."

    That stupid dying eagle really bothered me, and detracted from the soundtrack.

    Any soundtracks with little motif's that really bothered you?

    ~Shivered

    NP: "GoldenEye"

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-18-2000 04:59 PM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Oscar® Winner
     

    If we're thinking about the same sound effect, that damn dying eagle (which I always thought of as just "that falcon noise") has been used in every other Hollywood production, of ANY budget, since before RAIN MAN (which was the first to abuse the effect noticeably.) It got to be a joke with my father and me: either it would be a screaming cat thrown across the room for shock effect, or a majestic crying bird noise, for poignancy. It was always one or the other. It still is!

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 01:45 AM PT (US)     

     Widescreen
     Oscar® Winner
     

    That "bird noise" I think is created by a Japanese instrument called a Sakuhachi- and I agree, it should be used sparingly, something Horner used to know. I don't want to invite another damned debate about Horner- I love the man's scores from earlier in his career- but I don't think he's celebrated that past yet- the sooner he does, the sooner his scores will once again enjoy a renaissance. The man used to analyze and study the sources for which he'd create an approach. If the score for The Perfect Storm were a lot more like the rhythms of waves and a lot less an amalgam of Clear and Present Danger mixed with a pinch of Titanic, with a little of Braveheart thrown in for good groanage, then we would be sonically satisfied.

    How's that for a mouthful?

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 07:07 AM PT (US)     

     Scott
     Click Here to Email Scott
     Oscar® Winner
     

    I think Horner started using that instrument in Willow and it has become part of his signature. Well, kinda, sorta...


    Scott

    NP:Poltergeist (which gives me a great idea for a new thread)

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 07:52 AM PT (US)     

     Al
     Click Here to Email Al
     Oscar® Winner
     

    I could do without the Goblins motif from Goldsmith's "Legend."

    NP: A whole lot of nuthin'

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 08:37 AM PT (US)     

     Camillu
     Click Here to Email Camillu
     Oscar® Winner
     

    If it's the sound I think it is, it's used in legends of the Fall too. I bought both those CDs on the same day and got mixed up at night when I heard it in both of them.

    I'm personally not too fond of Jabba's theme from ROTJ, although I appreciate that it's good and serves its purpose well.

    NP - FIFA '98

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 09:05 AM PT (US)     

     John C Winfrey
     Click Here to Email John C Winfrey
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Don't forget Horner's Russian Bell/anchor clanking noise in almost every score. It is very annoying. Also his harsh piano music in Pelican Brief. Very annoying and distracting. Best, JW.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 02:44 PM PT (US)     

     Jens Dietrich
     Click Here to Email Jens Dietrich
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Well... that dying eagle sound is pretty damn annoying sometimes. And yes, it's caused by a so-called Shakashuchi flute. Horner seems to love this instrument since 'Willow' and uses it way too often, for my taste.

    However, there are more annoying sounds:

    1. That awful droning synth sound used by Elia Cmiral in EVERY SINGLE SCORE FROM 'RONIN' TO 'BATTLEFIELD GIRTH'!

    2. A terrible synthesized (or pre-recorded) solo voice saying "Ahmun dey". This was used in 'End of Days' EVERY SINGLE TIME GABRIEL BYRNE APPEARS ON SCREEN. It's also often used by Media Ventures, for example in 'Armageddon'.

    3. The annoying electric guitar riff whenever something "cool" appears on screen. It can be heard in most Media Ventures scores ('Armageddon', 'Drop Zone', 'K2', 'Enemy of the Ear'...)

    4. An awful and terribly sounding solo voice which starts whining whenever something sad or "emotional" happens. This can be heard in 'Gladiator', 'The Insider' and 'Mission Implausible 2'.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 03:31 PM PT (US)     

     Al
     Click Here to Email Al
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Jens, you have mentioned one that I HIGHLY agree with. Number one. I was listening to Battlefield Earth today and cringed every time I heard that "screeaach." Maybe that's not a most accurate portrayal, but that's what it comes off as in my ears.

    Sometimes this is used in scores to fill in atmospheric places. Like you said, Cmiral does this in every score. Then in Merlin, it was used to add power to big moments. I think that whenever this thing is used, it shows a sign of being slapped on. Composers should be a little more creative and find something more listenable to achieve the effect they want. Or at least that's what I think...


    NP: Goldsmith's "Medicine Man"

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 07:43 PM PT (US)     

     dantoris
     Click Here to Email dantoris
     Oscar® Winner
     

    The same effect that was in Ronin and Battlefield Earth (which I, personally, am not annoyed by but I knew a lot of people would be) is also used in Silvestri's rejected M:I score, though sparringly.

    A slightly-altered version of the same effect is used for the motif of the Ghost of Christmas Future in the fantastic George C. Scott version of A Christmas Carol (the best filmed adaptation of that story, by the way).

    [This message has been edited by dantoris (edited 19 July 2000).]

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-19-2000 08:28 PM PT (US)     

     Cole
     Click Here to Email Cole
     Oscar® Winner
     

    lol as soon as i saw the title of this thread one word jumped into my mind: "SHAKUHACHI"
    i am glad to see i am not the only one

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-20-2000 05:59 PM PT (US)     

     André Lux
     Click Here to Email André Lux
     Oscar® Winner
     


    I must remember you guys that the Sakauachi can be very enjoyable. Just check Bruce Smeaton's "Iceman"...

    But unfortunately James Horner overused it and now it became really anoying.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 07-20-2000 10:15 PM PT (US)     

     Hornerfan
     Click Here to Email Hornerfan
     Oscar® Winner
     

    quote:
    Originally posted by Jens Dietrich:

    2. A terrible synthesized (or pre-recorded) solo voice saying "Ahmun dey". This was used in 'End of Days' EVERY SINGLE TIME GABRIEL BYRNE APPEARS ON SCREEN. It's also often used by Media Ventures, for example in 'Armageddon'.


    The other stuff you posted here requires no comment. However, that example I quoted there just ****es me off. It clearly shows your complete and total ignorance when it comes to movie music that is not what you like. What the voice is saying is Agnus Dei, or Lamb of God for those not versed in Latin (like you, Jens). This is why people got mad at you over at Filmtracks, and it's annoying as hell. Think before you post, dammit.

    Mike

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 08:03 AM PT (US)     

     Jens Dietrich
     Click Here to Email Jens Dietrich
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Ok Hornerfan, it says "Agnus Dei". So what? Does that make it any less annoying?

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 08:46 AM PT (US)     

     Hornerfan
     Click Here to Email Hornerfan
     Oscar® Winner
     

    quote:
    Originally posted by Jens Dietrich:
    Ok Hornerfan, it says "Agnus Dei". So what? Does that make it any less annoying?

    No, it's not annoying, in the least. Quite ironic, actually, especially in the case of END OF DAYS. You really are narrow minded...

    Mike

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 08:50 AM PT (US)     

     Pete M
     Click Here to Email Pete M
     Oscar® Winner
     

    quote:
    Originally posted by André Lux:

    I must remember you guys that the Sakauachi can be very enjoyable. Just check Bruce Smeaton's "Iceman"...

    But unfortunately James Horner overused it and now it became really anoying.



    Yes, & also Goldsmith has made some very good uses of it too, such as in The Challenge, or Under Fire (was that Shakauachi?). And yes, I agree that Horner does use it too much, & not particularly interestingly either. Or maby that's just me.

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 08:56 AM PT (US)     

     Hornerfan
     Click Here to Email Hornerfan
     Oscar® Winner
     

    quote:
    Originally posted by Jens Dietrich:

    3. The annoying electric guitar riff whenever something "cool" appears on screen. It can be heard in most Media Ventures scores ('Armageddon', 'Drop Zone', 'K2', 'Enemy of the Ear'...)


    I said I wasn't going to comment on the rest, but I had to. The way you put it, it seems like it is the same guitar riff, everytime, in the scores you mentioned. There, for one, you are wrong. Listen to, say, the theme from ARMAGEDDON, then the theme from K2. Are they the same? No. Therefore, it is not an annoying electric guitar riff (singular). As a matter of fact, they aren't annoying, or are all electric guitar uses (except for Poledouris's FOR LOVE OF THE GAME), annoying, including Goldsmith's, as you have said in the past? Moreover, the electric guitar isn't even in MOST of Media Ventures' scores. It's only a handful of them, at most. I can list off more scores that DON'T use the guitar as you have listed there that do. You really do need to realize that someone will pick apart every single thing you say as wrong until you put more effort into your comments about scores, including Goldsmith (who isn't the best, especially now).

    Mike

    [This message has been edited by Hornerfan (edited 03 August 2000).]

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 09:07 AM PT (US)     

     Aaron Collins
     Click Here to Email Aaron Collins
     Oscar® Winner
     

    --------------------STOP--------------------

    The topic is not sounds or instruments that we dislike, it is "what motif's do you dislike?"

    Now the Sakauhachi(a very beautiful instrument), can be overused a little too much in Horner's scores. But, let me move on to motifs.

    A motif is often associated with the German composer Richard Wagner, the term applies to a short recognizable theme that is linked to a given character, object or concept within a show, opera or film score. In Wagner's 'Ring' cycle of operas, for instance, the main characters each have a leitmotif as do, in many cases, their horses and even Siegfried's sword. Leitmotifs are a potent tool in focusing the audience's attention by establishing a musical link to the visual action either before, after or during said action.

    THAT IS WHAT WE ARE DISCUSSING HERE!

    One motif that I absouletly hate is the main theme, presented by classical guitar, from the Princess Bride. I also usually do not care for Mediaventures "love" motifs. A while back it used to be that they would use a guitar for every single "romantic" theme.


    I have some more, but I am off to go practice on the horn.

    Later,
    Aaron Collins

    NP: Rio Conchos

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 10:57 AM PT (US)     

     Hornerfan
     Click Here to Email Hornerfan
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Aaron, I see where you're coming from in your argument. However, my argument was how Jens wrote it to mean the riff is the EXACT SAME! I just can't tolerate it when he, or anyone else, goes off assuming things, spouting off things that are simply untrue, whether he likes them or not. That's what I was attacking with my post. Sorry for misleading you with it.

    Mike

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 11:23 AM PT (US)     

     Aaron Collins
     Click Here to Email Aaron Collins
     Oscar® Winner
     

    Mike(Hornerfan),

    First off, welcome to Moviemusic.com. You will find this to be the best messageboard regarding film music on the net.

    In regards, to Jens and your argument, I understand what you were referring to and that's fine. I just made the statement that everyone on this post is referring to sounds rather than motifs.

    Latz,
    Aaron

    NP: Gremlins 2

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 11:53 AM PT (US)     

     H Rocco
     Oscar® Winner
     

    The formal Japanese name for the instrument is "shakuhachi." I'm not sure where the spelling "sakauhachi" started, but I was guilty of using it in the late eighties as well.

    Christopher Young used it beautifully in BAT-21, fortunately long before it had become a cliche. Some of Horner's early use of it was very clever, in WILLOW and even RED HEAT, but by the time of LEGENDS OF THE FALL, I was already tired of it. Of course, by the time of LEGENDS OF THE FALL, Horner had long since descended into complete laziness (although he's written a couple of decent tunes in the nineties, unless those too were stolen from Prokofiev. I won't even list the ones I liked so none of you can ruin them for me.)

    Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

    posted 08-03-2000 12:51 PM PT (US)     
     

    Old Infopop Software by UBB

    © 1998-2011, The MovieMusic Company