-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Musically Portraying God
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Musically Portraying God

joan hue

Oscar® Winner

We know that westerns, wars, fantasy, and science fiction
provide rich and original territories for film music composers.
While watching The Ten Commandments last night, I was
reminded of how magnificent some music is for portraying
God. What a conundrum it must be to find the right sound for
the figuration of divinity. A young, novice Bernstein composed
magnificent action music in The Ten Commandments, and his
lovely theme for God when Moses meets Him on the mountain
is sheer ethereal beauty.I can think of several other musical soundtracks the demonstrate
graceful divinity themes in their serene execution. Several themes
in Rozsa’s Ben Hur capture the perfect underscore for Christ/
God. His main theme for Christ in King of Kings always for me
has a tear-emerging emotional reaction. I’ll never forget as a
teen watching The Greatest Story Ever Told. When the camera
first shows the face of Max Von Sydow in the river, Alfred Newman’s
theme was knee dropping. The classical Handel’s Messiah with its
Hallelujah Chorus and For Unto Us a Child Is Born is another example
of DIVINE music.I see several NP’s refer to Jesus by Patrick Williams (?) Haven’t
heard that yet. What are some other musical pieces attributed to the
depiction of God that I’m not remembering or don’t know about?NP Peer Gynt Morning Mood seems inspirational
posted 04-17-2000 11:43 AM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Oscar® Winner

Oh, mom...you knew I'd be a sucker for this one.
Yeah, I caught part of The Ten Commandments on ABC last night, and was reminded once again just how magnificent every single measure of Bernstein's score is!
Does anyone know what score received the Oscar that year? It's difficult to imagine a better one...but then I always say that about all of my favorites.
It's also interesting that Bernstein captured the spiritual ambiance so beautifully without employing choral voices. Rozsa's and Newman's work that you cited above both made magnificent use of "church choir".
Cheesh! You pretty well nailed all of the examples I would have mentioned, except: Jerry Goldsmith's tremendous finale in The Final Conflict, the only movie (turkey that it is) that I know of to ever deal with the Second Coming of Jesus Christ, and Goldsmith's chorale ushers Him in magnificently!
John Williams' score for Close Encounters Of The Third Kind hit all of the "spiritual" buttons for that Shaggy God Story.
My mother always thought that the Ligeti piece accompanying the black monolith in 2001: A Space Odyssey was indicative of the presence of the Almighty. I can understand that somewhat, but for me that music is scarier than it is spiritual.
I can't wait to read the other examples...
GREAT TOPIC!NP: Masada Jerry
[This message has been edited by Chris Kinsinger (edited 17 April 2000).]
posted 04-17-2000 12:17 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

I can only repeat: Listen to anything by Anton Bruckner!
posted 04-17-2000 12:24 PM PT (US) 
JJH

Oscar® Winner

it's not really God per se, but I really think Williams Grail Theme does quite nicely.I would also add to Marian's Bruckner idea, that of listening to anything by Arvo Part, the Estonian composer, and John Tavener.
Those guys write some PHEnomenal music.
NP -- Somewhere in Time, re-recording Debneyposted 04-17-2000 12:31 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

Akira Ifukube's BUDDHA. He's done at least three versions of this, and I was fortunate to be at the concert premiere of the last one, in 1989. He wanted to revisit that work for three reasons: (A) the tapes of the original recordings were lost -- it was a classical piece in the 1940s or 1950s, then a larger version was written for the 1963 movie directed by Kenji Misumi (B) he hated the way it was mixed in the film anyway (not Misumi's fault, the tapes were sent for mixing by technicians in London, who didn't even know what the movie was about; and (C) he was growing older and I think revisiting this music represented, to him, some kind of compromise with the afterlife. He is probably surprised still to be with us. (I've said it many times before: chain-smoking those Dunhills out of the red box, that's got to be his secret. The sake with gold shavings in it probably doesn't hurt either.)I think it fascinating that he actually revisited this work in a subtler form a few years before, his "Sonata for Piano and Violin," which is basically a miniature version of the same music. When did he do it? Immediately after a severe health scare in 1984 (that helped keep him from doing GOJIRA '84, aka GODZILLA 1985). I guess the afterlife was much on his mind in the late eighties.
BUDDHA isn't a great movie, but the music is wrenching (although he's right about the mix), and the 1989 live recording is so phenomenal that I rarely listen to it -- it's just too emotionally taxing.
In a similar vein, much of Ifukube's score for the film THE BIRTH OF JAPAN deals with the legendary Shinto gods, but it's a quite different piece of work (and necessarily about three times as long). They have their own Adam and Eve story in Japan, and I believe Ifukube's pupil Toshiro Mayuzumi quoted bits of THE BIRTH OF JAPAN when he scored Adam and Eve for John Huston's film of THE BIBLE. (I almost wrote "John Huston's THE BIBLE," but I figured Christopher would jump on me for mistakenly implying he had written it.)
(a minute later: I just realized I didn't make one thing clear: except for the hard-core Buddhist monks, Japanese tend to be sort of polytheistic: they practice Shinto in daily life, and Buddhist practices for the dead. Hence, Ifukube's association of Buddha with the afterlife.)
[This message has been edited by H Rocco (edited 17 April 2000).]
[This message has been edited by H Rocco (edited 17 April 2000).]
posted 04-17-2000 12:40 PM PT (US) 
Rang
Oscar® Winner

Victor Young won the Oscar for his score to AROUND THE WORLD IN 80 DAYS in 1956. Didn't he "receive" it posthumously, though?Good selections all-around. I'd add Newman's THE ROBE (and Waxman's follow-up to that, DEMETRIUS AND THE GLADIATORS) and THE SONG OF BERNADETTE to the list as well.
posted 04-17-2000 02:16 PM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Oscar® Winner

Joan, I was just about to remind everyone what a good week this is on TV for God music (it's Easter here, don't know about in other places).All week, at any time and on any channel, you can bathe in truly wondrous God music from big-budget Hollywood spectaculars. I love it all, and it really does reach to my soul. I sometimes think that I shouldn't get carried away, because those who have labelled me an atheist in the past see a contradiction, but I can't help it. I love God music!
Even today, composers turn out good God stuff. Just last night I caught part of another version of the Jesus story. It had some amusing bits in it as when the Devil (played, I think, by him who was the main baddie in The Fugitive) turned up in a Giorgio Armani suit and took Jesus on a whirlwind tour of wars and suffering, but even for such a mediocre TV thing, the music was still first rate. Nothing terribly original (I want all my God music to sound like Rozsa and Alfred Newman anyway), but still affecting. Maybe that was the Bruce Broughton-scored thing? I didn't catch the credits.
posted 04-17-2000 02:24 PM PT (US) 
PeterK

FishChip

While the subject matter of Black Robe and Agnes of God isn't altogether heavenly, Georges Delerue's music is very moving. Just a few off the top of my head...PeterK
NP - "East/West" by Doyle
posted 04-17-2000 02:28 PM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Oscar® Winner

Satan in Giorgio Armani?
Are you sure you weren't watching The Devil's Advocate with Al Pacino?
"(I almost wrote "John Huston's THE BIBLE," but I figured Christopher would jump on me for mistakenly implying he had written it.)"
Oh, I don't know, Rocco...Huston was a god (small "g") himself, so I would've easily forgiven such an error.
posted 04-17-2000 02:33 PM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Oscar® Winner

Maurice Jarre's score for the TV Mini-Series Jesus Of Nazareth is wonderful "God music" (I LOVE that, Graham!) also.
I have a copy of the Italian CD, in which the Beattitudes are spoken...in Italian. Since I don't know the language, I always wind up laughing out loud whenever I play it, because it always reminds me of those old Italian Hercules flicks...
posted 04-17-2000 02:37 PM PT (US) 
mlw
Oscar® Winner

I'm always up for some of that Ave Satani!
posted 04-17-2000 02:38 PM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Oscar® Winner

"Hail mlw!"
posted 04-17-2000 02:39 PM PT (US) 
mlw
Oscar® Winner

G's Star Trek is about as cosmic as it gets-- all about those yin/yang principles of creation/destruction embodied in Ilia's uber-female, a soaring affirmation of being alive through the classic ideals of quest and learning to feel.I also like Poledouris' complex spiritual thesis explored in Conan the Barbarian-- let us grab this world by the throat and make it give us what we desire! The ideals of ancient Greece expounded with the emphasis on deed and strength of character over rationale and poetry. If Crom does not listen, then to HELL with him! See also Lonesome Dove.
Williams' Jurassic Park for it's challenging Olympian overview to action and reaction, a pristinely beautiful paen to the natural world worthy of Takemitsu, Ifukube. Check also (like you don't have it!) The Five Sacred Trees, and the Flute Concerto.
Ifukube's sublime elegy for that natural world in Gojira.
online column (which I already recycled at the FSM board): http://seen.kcisp.net/filmusic.html
http://seen.kcisp.net/contents.html
[This message has been edited by mlw (edited 17 April 2000).][This message has been edited by mlw (edited 17 April 2000).]
posted 04-17-2000 03:15 PM PT (US) 
Bulldog
Oscar® Winner

STAR TREK V is really beautiful musical portrait rendering.
posted 04-17-2000 06:37 PM PT (US) 
Lancelot

Oscar® Winner

As far as musical representation goes...I think Hans Zimmer's "Prince of Egypt"--The Burning Bush....does excellent.
posted 04-17-2000 09:12 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

<huff> you just beat me to it Lancelot
posted 04-17-2000 09:22 PM PT (US) 
Timmer

Oscar® Winner

Nobody gonna mention David Newman's wonderful Music for Heaven/Hell in BILL & TED'S BOGUS ADVENTURE?!
This is in My top 5 wanted unreleased scores!In the meantime there's VAUGHAN WILLIAMS Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis, the most beautiful,Ecstatic,Spine Tingling piece of Religious Music ever written!!
I wouldn't even dream of giving this a 'numbered' rating!posted 04-18-2000 04:37 PM PT (US) 
mlw
Oscar® Winner

Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey--
that's a FILM, man!
American Cinema!
Whoa!I liked D. Newman's work on both B&Ts.
posted 04-18-2000 05:45 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

How about....... Alfred Newman's score for "The Greatest Story Ever Told" ????Oh.... whoops, Joan already mentioned that.
Jeron
[This message has been edited by Jeron (edited 18 April 2000).]
posted 04-18-2000 06:29 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

Whoa! Mr. Ware actually appreciates BOGUS JOURNEY? (The movie, I mean.) (As opposed to the soundtrack, or even merely the concept of a bogus journey. But whom among us has not been subjected to such a one.) (I was subjected to the most ridiculous pointless trip to Jersey once ... )I don't really remember Newman's scores for the two BILL & TED pictures, but I'm sure they were competent. (blush) in fact, I liked the songs better in both cases, particularly "I Can't Break Away" from the original (it's the main title sequence).
posted 04-18-2000 08:08 PM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Oscar® Winner

Weird "God" Moments In Film Music:That wonderfully alien, yet recognizably religious music Maurice Jarre composed for the final scene (one of my all-time favorites!) in Enemy Mine.
Bernard Herrmann's harps, bells & strings accompanying Zeus & Co. in Jason And The Argonauts.
posted 04-18-2000 08:15 PM PT (US) 
James

Oscar® Winner

I've enjoyed Prince of Egypt ever since it came out, despite Zimmer's constant complaints about how "ridiculously impossible" it was to score the burning bush sequence.I enjoy this thread because it gives me the chance to ask a question I've been meaning to ask...
A week or so ago I saw a TV advertisement for a video called Charleton Heston Presents The Bible featuring Charleton Heston reading stories from the Bible in the locations where they are thought to have taken place. One of the "call right now" deals was they would include a tape of the program's orchestral score, composed by Leonard Rosenman. They played it during the promotion and it sounded astounding... Golden-Age Rosza-style stuff. Has anyone heard this who can comment on it?
James
NP - watching "Jason and the Argonauts"[This message has been edited by James (edited 18 April 2000).]
posted 04-18-2000 08:40 PM PT (US) 
Andre Lux
unregistered
Whenever I listen to Morricone's "THE MISSION" (particulary "On Earth as it is in Heaven" and "Miserere") I feel in heaven...Goldsmith's "Second Coming" from "THE FINAL CONFLICT" and "Everywhere" from "POWDER" are great examples of music from God...
As for Hans Zimmer's "Prince of Egypt" Burning Bush motif, I always preffer the original - "The Nexus" from Dennis McCarthy's "GENERATIONS".
posted 04-19-2000 12:57 PM PT (US) 
Audacity

Oscar® Winner

The latest edition of Film Score Monthly has an Interview with Howard Shore. In it he talks about how hard it was to score Dogma, since he is not Catholic and he knows next to nothing about the religion. I found it interesting and the whole interview was great.Audacity
posted 04-20-2000 07:18 AM PT (US) 
mlw
Oscar® Winner

It was always fascinating to get such powerfully significant bouts of introspection as to what it is basically to live in scores by the non-religious Alfred Newman (The Greatest Story Ever Told is second only to Diary Of Anne Franke in my op). It's always interesting to hear how non-religious John Williams actually scores a religion in his Star Wars music.Np: GODzilla vs MechaGODzilla II
[This message has been edited by mlw (edited 20 April 2000).]
posted 04-20-2000 07:36 AM PT (US) 
Scorro
Oscar® Winner

I find Black Robe (Delerue) to be an inspirational score with a strong feeling of the divine woven in. Here we have the meeting of 2 cultures, each not understanding the other's perspective of reality and god.
_Sc
posted 04-20-2000 09:09 AM PT (US) 
Graham Watt

Oscar® Winner

What exactly was Howard Shore's problem with Dogma? He may not be Catholic, but I can think of plenty of great SF and horror scores which weren't written by aliens or vampires.
posted 04-21-2000 07:58 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

quote:
Originally posted by mlw:
It's always interesting to hear how non-religious John Williams actually scores a religion in his Star Wars music.Hm, I find the Force theme VERY religious (it could even qualify for "Musically Portraying God", I think). Also, "The Dark Side Beckons" is very religious-sounding. Thor, were are you!?
posted 04-21-2000 09:05 AM PT (US) 
Thor

Oscar® Winner

Transcript from my article at my website "Celluloid Tunes":-------------------
"John Williams - the Medium?"
~A look at the maestro's "religious" sound~I must admit that I'm not a very religious person. Yes, I'm a christian, but not to the extent that I am a regular sunday church-goer, I'm afraid.
Nevertheless, I've always "been drawn to" (to quote a certain lawyer) the power that is inherent in musical works that describe and evoke a higher being, such as Mozart's "Requiem", Händel's "Messiah"-chorus or Barber's "Adagio for Strings".
So, what do I mean exactly - "religious sound"? Well, I think it's quite self-explanatory. What separates humans from beasts, to quote Descartes, is our ability to think and ponder our own existence. In so doing, many feel a great desire to comfort and assure themselves of their rightful place in the universe. Usually, this is done by BELIEVING in a higher being, a being that is our own creator. After all, if we are able to believe in something higher, someone or something must have put that thought into us initially. We are in constant search for this something or this creator (like V'ger in STAR TREK: THE MOTION PICTURE!), and a way this Being manifests itself in our daily lives is through art - man's ability to utilize God's gift, if you will.
Music is certainly one of these mediums of divine communication. Through history, many composers have tried to nail that particular "voice of God" in their works, some more successfully than others. I've mentioned Mozart and Händel already . John Williams is, although perhaps not as influential, still as capable of speaking and getting in touch with that inner religiousity as the latter two...
Actually, to put it more bluntly, no one has been able to move me "religiously" in a more profound way than my favourite composer - John Williams. And it's quite ironical, seeing as his reputation is usually tied to the grand and epic swashbucklers, the melodic fanfares and marches and not the subdued majesty of his religious compositions.
As a matter of fact, I would go so far as to say (and it's my theory) that Williams' trademark sound NOT is the neo-romantic Korngold-approach, but rather his incredible insight into what is universally considered religious; a majestic, haunting, spine-tingling, hair-rising sound that moves people.
There are a lot of examples of this in his prolific career, dating back to the very beginning, especially when he was not in the usual jazz-mode. The sound even features prominently in works such as STAR WARS, although it unfortunately is overshadowed (popular-wise) by the action material.
Let me proceed, then, to provide you with a few examples. See if you can form the pattern yourself:
"Main Titles" from SGT. RYKER (1968)
"Restoration" from JANE EYRE (1970)
"Blood Moon" from IMAGES (1972, this one's arguable, though)
"Appearance of the Visitors" from CLOSE ENCOUNTERS (1977)
"Main Title" from THE FURY (1978)
"The Ark Theme" from RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK (1981)
"Gloria" from MONSIGNOR (1982)
"The Emperor's Theme" from RETURN OF THE JEDI (1983)
"Cadillac of the Skies" from EMPIRE OF THE SUN (1987)
"Only the Penitant Will Pass" from IJ & THE LAST CRUSADE (1989)
"Star of Bethlehem" from HOME ALONE (1990)
"You are the Pan" from HOOK (1991)
"Remembrances" from SCHINDLER'S LIST (1993)
"Journey to the Island" from JURASSIC PARK (1993, a majestic variation)
"Meeting With Mao" from NIXON (1995)
"Duel of the Fates" from STAR WARS: THE PHANTOM MENACE (1999)
"Angela's Prayer" from ANGELA'S ASHES (1999)
Well, I guess you've got the clue by now. All these excerpts, ranging more than 30 years showcase a style in Williams' music that, in my opinion, is both vastly underrated and neglected. It's why I love him so much, and will continue to, because whenever you think the creative well has gone dry, Williams serves us something from up his magic sleeve that is both captivating and aweinspiring.But more importantly, it's a sound that INSPIRES - whether you're an artist or not, and that is truly the gift of a man who posesses almost religious powers himself....
----------------
That's it. Sorry for the long post. I'm starting to turn into a certain mr. D...
posted 04-26-2000 10:16 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Return of the Jedi - why do you list the Emperor's theme here, and not that cue which we both like to mention over and over again on these occasions?
NP: Sticky Fingers (the album that made me a Rolling Stones fan)
posted 04-26-2000 10:26 AM PT (US) 
Sharol

Oscar® Nominee

The music to the excellent mini series "Jesus of Nazarath" is my favorite.
posted 04-26-2000 10:47 AM PT (US) 
Timmer

Oscar® Winner

Hi Thor,ol'freind,
Continuing your list...Symphonies 2 ,3 ,5 ,6 ,7, and Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis, Oboe Concerto and probably a few I missed?!
All by Ralph Vaughan Williams!!....To see where The Master of Film music (and I believe Williams to be The Best living composer around!) has been influenced, and in a Religious context, Heavily (or should that be Heavenly
)NP : nothing
posted 04-26-2000 11:00 AM PT (US) 
Ron Pulliam

Oscar® Winner

I was scanning this thread and saw John Williams' name mentioned several times, but did not see anyone mention "E.T."Surely, if any movie Williams ever scored had a "Christ" figure, it was this one. We even had the shot of E.T. emerging from the back of that stolen van -- covered in a robe, arms outstretched, with steam surrounding him...a take on the resurrection if I've ever seen one!
And I second, third or whatever the number is all comments made about Alfred Newman -- this man had a talent for inspirational scoring. One nobody seems to have mentioned is "David and Bathsheba," the end of which features a choral composition set to "The Lord's Prayer." And also "The Egyptian" -- which most certainly deals with the first Pharaoh to recognize "one" god...Aton. The music Newman scored around the text "How Beautiful Art Thou" (Hymn to Aton) is very beautiful. The sequence called "Death of Akhnaton" is one of the finest scored scenes in film -- Sinuhe has administered a lethal poison to pharaoh, who explains his belief and devotion to the one god. As pharaoh dies, he utters, "He forgives everyone; he forgives you." Newman's music for pharaoh and Hymn to Aton is so sensitively scored under this sequence that it's heartbreaking. And the finale is incredible.
Ah, well.
Ron
posted 04-26-2000 01:18 PM PT (US) 
SBD
Oscar® Winner

I thought I was the only one who liked BILL & TED'S BOGUS JOURNEY (movie AND score). The scenes in Hell and Heaven were very funny and very well scored. Is it just me, or should David Newman use choirs in his scores more often?NP - The Phantom ("The Escape")
posted 05-12-2000 08:47 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
