-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
A Summer Place/in praise of Max Steiner
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: A Summer Place/in praise of Max Steiner

Howard L
Standard Userer

A Summer Place.Peyton Place again, only this time away from the mainland. Cliched? Somewhat. Outdated, perhaps laughable dialogue? At times (Molly's "naughty dreams"!). But the movie unravels the pretentious pseudo-priggish alleged mores of the 1950s in a manner that isn't shocking now but must have been considered bold for its day.
And then there's Max Steiner's music. Cliched? Only when that sly, leery sax oils its way across the ears while underscoring sexual tension. Repetitive? Yeah. Overblown? Maybe, yet an absolute joy nonetheless. And that's the genius of Max Steiner: his music brings dignity to an otherwise mundane albeit stylish B-movie. What does he dignify? Human longings, 'little' things like newly-found love, old love rekindled, unspoken passions, hopes, shattered dreams...and damaged lives. Oh yes--with real live melodies that pull you in and make you forget that you're watching a potboiler.
That's what first comes to mind when I think of the genius of Max Steiner: elevating a simple soap opera to dignified heights. I think of the "Belle Watling Theme" when Melanie thanks the madam-with-a-heart in Gone With The Wind; the ending of Now Voyager; the love story with the platinum blonde and the big ape; and in A Summer Place the close-ups of Dorothy Maguire, especially during the early scene at the dinner table in the inn.
Steiner basically employed variations of 4 love themes throughout the picture. Let me call them 1) the Adult Love Theme introduced during the opening credits; 2) the Teen Love Theme made memorable and best-selling by Percy Faith and his orchestra; 3) the Sex Theme, already alluded to in accordance with its arrangement for the 'devil's instrument'; and finally 4) the Innocent Love Theme introduced in Molly's good-night to Papa.
I recommend you ignore the cloying harp and vibraphone (?) arrangement of the latter and savor the string arrangement employed the 2nd time around; either way, all 4 are pure listening pleasures. It's just such a shame the entire score has never been released, so far as I know. Warner Brothers has an ignominious reputation for having discarded original soundtrack sources and it wouldn't surprise if this one is among those lost forever. If worse comes to worse, get a video (I'm told the film's an excellent transfer to tape) and just watch/listen to the first 45 minutes. You will not be disappointed. Guaranteed.
posted 04-08-2000 12:32 PM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

Took a little of my own medicine and watched those first 45 minutes last night. There is something positively enchanting generated by the music right over the WB logo that segues right into the ocean and the opening titles. I mean it's the difference between going to "the movies" and "the picture show." We are talking excitement, anticipation! It's the same way with the opening of Casablanca. The funny thing, though, about Casablanca is that the opening titles music the 2nd, 3rd, etc. viewing cracks me up. It's so bold and epic sounding the 1st time but when you know all the seedy little characters & goings on that are to follow...I start laughing! But in a I-can't-believe-how-good-this-is-going-to-be way.The list goes on: Treasure Of Sierra Madre, The Searchers...this guy was associated with a helluva lot of great flicks. A Summer Place was not a great flick, but THE MUSIC!
posted 04-10-2000 07:09 AM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Standard Userer

...and I thought you brought this up because Steiner's theme from "A Summer Place" is the first track on FSM's new release of "The Omega Man"!
Sorry to burst your bubble, Howard.
Time to put your photo in your Member Profile.
posted 04-10-2000 07:47 AM PT (US) 
Luscious Lazlo

Standard Userer

Greetings from the Oral Roberts University video library. Where, for the sake of Howard, I just suffered thru a crappy cartoonish excretion called A SUMMER PLACE. What a piece of boring wet-fart drivel. Howard, you really put me thru hell this time. Those cardboard characters drove me up the wall. Molly's priggish mother is a ludicrous stick-figure. Dorothy McGuire is not my idea of a good-looking broad. Sandra Dee's kewpie-doll face didn't impress me. (Although I thought Sandra did a better acting job than Troy Donahue.) I have total contempt for that horny irresponsible Troy Donahue character. But I did enjoy Richard Egan's deep rich euphonious voice. And I was impressed by Arthur Kennedy's ability to act drunk.Remember when Johnny & Molly got stranded overnight on that island? And after they got rescued, Molly's mother hires a doctor to give Molly a physical in order to determine if Molly is still a virgin. What a hoot. Another hoot was provided by 3 separate successive shots that show 3 people reacting to shocking information. Steiner's 3 successive sting chords cracked me up. Constance Ford's Swede-bashing was another highlight. Needless to say, it's totally implausible that Richard Egan would ever have married Constance Ford in the first place.
If I remember correctly, the Lascivious Sax Theme underwent 2 variations. During the dinner-table scene, there's a string version. Another version is heard when Johnny & Molly go back to Pine Island to tell Arthur Kennedy that they're getting married. It's an eerie version with a nautical rhythm-section, and Steiner put the sax in an echo chamber. I also liked the sax version of the Young Love Theme. But I sorta begrudge Steiner for putting it to such hackneyed manipulative Pavlovian effect during those close-ups of Sandra Dee.
Regarding the Innocent Love Theme: You could also call this the Girls School theme. Because I think that's the only scene where that theme is used. I didn't consider the vibe & harp version to be cloying. (By the way, Howard, an unplugged unelectrified vibraphone is called a metallophone. Or at least that's what Steve Reich calls it.)
Regarding the Adult Love Theme in the opening credits: I like how Steiner synced the crashing white waves with the shimmering cymbals. It's cheap & corny, but it's also a wonderful gimmick.
posted 04-10-2000 09:12 AM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

"Howard, you really put me thru hell this time."Whydaya think I said the first 45 minutes, you maroon. And didn't you read the caveats all through my original post? the last sentence of the follow-up??
"Dorothy McGuire is not my idea of a good-looking broad."
Do you recall her line the first meeting in the boathouse about not being as pretty as before? The camera captured her deep beauty within. You missed it.
"Richard Egan's deep rich euphonious voice."
He had a tremendous screen presence. Anyway, when all's said & done the music remains the thing. And the deep blue sea.
[This message has been edited by Howard L (edited 10 April 2000).]
posted 04-10-2000 02:36 PM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Standard Userer

My favorite part was imagining Luscious at Oral Roberts University!
posted 04-10-2000 09:30 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Standard Userer

pure cheese. his movie gets points in my book for being pure cheese. but cheese that makes you think - I mean, this picture touched some very racy issues when it came out; and now the issues are so trivial to our society. perhaps its a shame that we consider a movie dealing with an issue such as premarital sex to be cheesy and silly.
nonetheless...its still cheese "I washed my hair for you Johnny."
"you kiss by the book" "I learned at buffalo high school. we used to sneak up on the roof during gym class"
wow - I mean cheese. but you gotta love cheese
NP - The Man From Snowy River
posted 04-11-2000 01:46 AM PT (US) 
PeterD

Standard Userer

Getting back for a moment to Mr. Steiner . . . In the early days of my soundtrack collecting, I never put him very high up on my list of favorite film composers, although I had heard quite a bit of his stuff on the Gerhardt LPs; but in the last couple of years, I've come to appreciate his music a lot more.For people who haven't heard much of his music, I'd recommend the compilation CD "The Flame and the Arrow: Classic Film Music of Max Steiner" as a good introduction. Two of my favorite suites from the CD are "The Dark at the Top of the Stairs" and "The Hanging Tree"; I've seen both of these movies at least a couple of times each on TV, but didn't realize until listening to the CD how much Steiner's scores contributed to their effect. (Some of the others on the album I enjoy, in addition to "Flame and the Arrow": "Ice Palace," "The FBI Story," "Sergeant York" and "Johnny Belinda.")
Another favorite of mine is his "Charge of the Light Brigade," well-represented on Marco Polo's "Historical Romances" CD.
And his "Distant Drums" score, released by Screen Archives Entertainment.
posted 04-11-2000 07:11 AM PT (US) 
Sid Mysterioso
unregistered
MEMO TO COLE: Did Troy Donahue really say "You kiss by the book"? I guess I missed that. As it stands to chance, that line was also addressed by Juliet Capulet to Romeo Montague. I just thought I'd let you know that *I* know.[This message has been edited by Sid Mysterioso (edited 14 April 2000).]
posted 04-13-2000 07:44 AM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

"Getting back for a moment to Mr. Steiner...but in the last couple of years, I've come to appreciate his music a lot more."Out of curiosity, it is a matter of you're just discovering the movies he underscored or soundtracks on CDs or both? There was a thread on the FSM site about this sort of thing; went into the level of interest (or lack of interest) in older films and how it may correlate with composer awareness. Just the same, Steiner was credited as "Music Supervisor" on Lost Horizon which, of course, contained another great Tiomkin score. One of the earliest flicks (1937) I know of to feature significant choral cues.
Max Steiner & Dmitri Tiomkin--now isn't THAT a powerhouse combo if ever there were.
posted 04-15-2000 10:18 AM PT (US) 
Chris Kinsinger

Standard Userer

Cole...BEHOLD! The Power Of CHEESE!

posted 04-15-2000 10:47 AM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Standard Userer

My first roar of the day, Christopher ...What's next, a WRITTEN ON THE WIND thread? (I love that enormous score cue where impotent Robert Stack is staring at the little boy in the cowboy outfit on the mechanical horse. And that wonderful scene where Dorothy Malone kills her father by dancing upstairs to all the sexy music. Did the Mystery Science Theater people ever get to this one? It'd be pointless, it's funny and self-aware enough as it is. That wacky Douglas Sirk.)
NP: space heater humming at my feet (why is it so cold this April?)
[This message has been edited by H Rocco (edited 15 April 2000).]
posted 04-15-2000 11:48 AM PT (US) 
RoboKennyRogers
unregistered
MEMO TO: Rocco the Omniscient
RE: Douglas SirkYou probably already know this, but Rainer Werner Fassbinder was an idolator of Douglas Sirk. Who said the Germans have no sense of irony? Fassbinder overdosed on barbituate a bunch of years ago. But luckily for us, Fassbinder's ghost is alive & well and is currently inhabiting Howard Liverance's haunted cannister of Cheez-Wiz.
posted 04-15-2000 02:40 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Standard Userer

Omniscient as I am, of course I knew about the Fassbinder connection, but don't much care about it, as I have sat through only three Fassbinder pictures, and that is more than enough. I mentioned on another thread that life is just too short to contemplate sitting through all four hundred hours of BERLIN ALEXANDERPLATZ.His colleague Kurt Raab, who is also presently dead (and will no doubt remain so for the forseeable future), made a movie I liked somewhat more, entitled ESCAPE FROM BLOOD PLANTATION. Original German title is ISLAND OF THE BLOODY PLANTATION. Great (English language!) theme song as well, I should move this discussion over to the Song thread.)
("on the iiiiii-land [drum roll] of the BLUD-dy plan-TA-tion ... " I'm yearning for ABBA to get back together and do a cover of that one.)
Another Sirk fan, and a filmmaker I respect more, is the estimable lunatic John Waters. There's a cover story about him in the current CULT MOVIES magazine, although it came out in January or so, might be sold out. Basil and Zoe Poledouris are scoring (already scored?) his newest, CECIL B. DEMENTED.
Actually, in honesty (am I ever less than honest? frankly, it is my curse), I've only seen the one Sirk film I mentioned. There's other things in the universe of movies that I'd rather catch up with ... but I did read a synopsis of MAGNIFICENT OBSESSION, and it looks so nuts that I might rent it one day, but it would have to be that PARTICULAR day. (I've already taken out Altman's M*A*S*H, which I haven't seen in fifteen years, and the so-called "collector's edition" of VANISHING POINT -- curious if this restores the few minutes of "desert" footage that got cut -- in tone these could hardly be more opposite than WRITTEN ON THE WIND, so that sufficiently illustrates my present frame of mind.)
NP: nothing, I don't feel like popping in a CD and my RealPlayer has balked on me. I have to reload it with whatever the updated stuff is, but I tried it and it wouldn't do it. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrr. Try again later ...
P.S. Howard, CHECK that Cheez-Whiz, and make SURE it's not rattling funny before you open it. I could scarcely imagine a more tedious haunt ...
posted 04-15-2000 02:57 PM PT (US) 
PeterD

Standard Userer

Howard, in answer to your question . . . I think it's mostly due to the greater availability of Steiner's scores on CD. I've always liked his music for "The Treasure of Sierra Madre," "The Caine Mutiny" and "Johnny Belinda," but most of the other stuff I mentioned in my earlier posting has only become available on CD in the last few years. (I'm definitely looking forward to Marco Polo's complete-score recording of "Treasure of Sierra Madre.")
posted 04-15-2000 06:54 PM PT (US) 
joan hue

Standard Userer

So we now have traversed from a Steiner, sweet, “Look at
me I’m Sandra Dee,” flick to regards for John Waters and Cult
Movie articles. I read that one. Very illuminating and well written!
But there are certain Waters’ movies I doubt I’ll ever rent.
Neat! One of my favorites, Basil Poledouris, will be scoring Cecil B.
Demented. So I have to ask, your H’ness, if this will be a satire
on the late, great DeMille or a brand new character? Any
insights or rumors about the plot?Let’s see. This week I’ve seen H Rocco travel from Ifukube to
John Waters, to bikini clad ladies mud wrestling (I know, you
were forced into that by one Chris
) to zillions of Japanese names
probably ALL spelled correctly. To quote an Edward Albee play,
“I (meaning Hank) do have a certain catholicity of taste.” Do you
have a photographic memory? Best, Mom. (Shoot, adopted
Internet mom; can’t even take credit for the gene pool of Chris
and Hank.)NP White Fang II Debney Very Americana
[This message has been edited by joan hue (edited 15 April 2000).]
posted 04-15-2000 10:43 PM PT (US) 
Lou Goldberg

Standard Userer

I'm a fan of both Fassbinder and Sirk--far from A Summer Place and Steiner though.NP: Simpatico (Stewart Copeland)
posted 04-15-2000 11:33 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Standard Userer

Mom made me howl ... sorry I've been away from this particular thread for so long.I think you're cheating yourself by not seeing Mr. Waters' DESPERATE LIVING, no matter how gory it is. I would never recommend PINK FLAMINGOS to anyone, however.
Basil Poledouris also did the lushly cheesy, VERTIGO-like score for Mr. Waters' earlier SERIAL MOM. I remain convinced that the director chose Poledouris because he had done THE BLUE LAGOON and SUMMER LOVERS for the director of those films, Randal Kleiser.
What his daughter Zoe Poledouris is contributing to the score, I don't have a single clue, but she was working with her father as early as CONAN THE BARBARIAN -- she shared credit for the "Orgy" cue, and she was an infant at the time. No doubt a tune she came up with and he interpolated -- sweet of him to give her credit.
(Curious the number of film composers that give their daughters the name "Zoe." Besides Basil Poledouris, we know of Michael Kamen, and didn't Hans Zimmer also name a daughter Zoe? I'm less sure about that last one though.)
NP: 100 RIFLES (Jerry Goldsmith) (FSM version) (stereo section)
posted 04-16-2000 10:37 PM PT (US) 
joan hue

Standard Userer

Well, I'll think about renting Desperate Living. Maybe the stores won't have it. Hope it isn't in one of those BACK rooms in the video stores that only those guys flashing ID (half crouched) walk into. Then I'll also rent something sweet (Disney) for counter balance.NP nothing, like Chris, watching Ten Commandments, remembering how many unbelievable themes Bernstein (a very young, novice Bernstein) wrote for this movie. Had it on LP. May have to order the CD. Lovely!
posted 04-16-2000 11:01 PM PT (US) 
joan hue

Standard Userer

And you never said if you have a photographic memory. You must!
posted 04-16-2000 11:03 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Standard Userer

Mom,I don't have a PHOTOGRAPHIC memory, I have a WEIRD one. I can perfectly spell the name of the third assistant floor-sweeper from that picture NOTHING YOU EVER HEARD OF (Japanese, what was the year?), but I couldn't tell you what color my socks are without checking. Although that one's actually easy, I rarely wear socks except to go out in the weather. Mostly I wear white and gray ones until they wear out and become unspeakable.
Don't know Albee's work except for the ridiculous "Who's Afraid Of Virgina Woolf." As for my range of fiction tastes, well, as I've written elsewhere, "It's manifest I'm a lunatic." (I CANNOT remember which author I stole that from ... whoa, I just did, Darryl Brock, who wrote one of my favorite novels, the amazing "If I Never Get Back." Miss it at your own peril.)
NP: 100 RIFLES (FSM version, now we're into the mono sections, but I love this music so much that I do not feel like switching it -- you wouldn't either if you were hearing this astonshing cue "Escape and Pursuit")
P.S. It's HATFIELD who has the photographic memory, as well as a thing or two else we've been waiting for. Go pick on him.
[This message has been edited by H Rocco (edited 17 April 2000).]
posted 04-16-2000 11:14 PM PT (US) 
TimT

Standard Userer

This CD was released at SAE a few weeks ago. Is it worth getting? Is it big and symphonic like Gone with the Wind?
posted 12-03-2003 02:22 PM PT (US) 
Dinko

Standard Userer

quote:
Originally posted by TimT:
Is it worth getting? Is it big and symphonic like Gone with the Wind?uhm... symphonic? What else should it be? I don't think Mr. Steiner knew the synth-banging technique.

(sorry! I know what you meant, I just had to say it
)posted 12-03-2003 03:09 PM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

It's not "worth getting".
'S a must. And I's gots mine already.And I's can't stop laughing over that sly sax! But this really is a tremendous stand-alone listening experience. What I have referred to as a cloying arrangement of "innocent love" theme when Molly says good-night to Ken (track: A Filthy Word) is nothing of the sort when heard on its own. Positively lovely celeste melody made lovelier with the ensuing string arrangement.
{man, can't believe this old thread's been resurrected
}
*****************************************************************[Message edited by Howard L on 12-03-2003]
posted 12-03-2003 03:34 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little

Standard Userer

dude i don't need this ablum cuz i have the track on OMEGA MAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!My Max Steiner collection is currently (sadly) just the old Mathieson re-recording of Gone with the Wind and the Gerhardt album.

posted 12-03-2003 04:13 PM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

Yeah, that theme made famous by Percy Faith also appeared in Matinee and then was parodied by Mr. Goldsmith. And it's also been Simpsonized, as we all know.
posted 12-03-2003 04:36 PM PT (US) 
Dana Wilcox

Standard Userer

quote:
Originally posted by Howard L:
Yeah, that theme made famous by Percy Faith also appeared in [b]Matinee and then was parodied by Mr. Goldsmith. And it's also been Simpsonized, as we all know.
[/B]Not bad for an almost-72-year-old guy (talking about Steiner, not Howard!
). The theme ranks with the best of the film themes that have reached the popular consciousness -- MAGNIFICENT 7, EXODUS, LAURA, "Tara's Theme" from GWTW, a very few others in that stratum. I've been listening to the wonderful BYU release repeatedly but not analytically (i.e., without reference to film or liner notes), and love the way it flows. So many wonderful themes besides the one we all know. The reference to "Belle Watling's Theme" from GWTW is apt here -- even the smaller moments are so graced musically by Steiner's devotion to the emotional content of a story. Great stuff, I'm really pleased to have this one in my collection!posted 12-06-2003 09:33 AM PT (US) 
CAT

Standard Userer

As a movie...Outdated? Most definately, but nostalgic just the same...a throw-back to more innocent and naive days of our youth (mine anyway). Cheesy? Maybe, but nothing wrong with a little cheese from time to time.
The theme...I grew up with it. It's literally been in my head and part of my life since I was a young girl, and I will always consider it one of the most beautiful themes written for film or otherwise.CAT
posted 12-06-2003 08:12 PM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

Hey Dana--that Belle Watling scene with Melanie in the carriage remains a powerful listening (and viewing) experience. Caught it twice in the recent cable broadcasts {amazing how much time there is to watch movies when you're flat on yer back
}
posted 01-06-2004 08:35 PM PT (US) 
jonathan_little

Standard Userer

So how does this new album sound? I see it's from the mag tracks, which is a big plus. Any significant wow?
posted 01-06-2004 10:00 PM PT (US) 
Howard L
Standard Userer

Nope. In fact, I'm listening to it right now. 'S wonderful, 's marvelous.
posted 01-07-2004 06:56 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
