-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
who should score "Tomb Raider?" (Page 1)
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2Author
Topic: who should score "Tomb Raider?"

dantoris

Wizard

Provided the darn thing ever gets made, of course. The obvious choice would be either Goldsmith (think "The Mummy") or Williams doing his Indiana Jones thingy again. Personally, if I was making it, I'd go with Goldsmith, just because he's my all-time favorite composer. Either choice would be perfect, but I'm curious as to who you would like to see score the flick.
posted 02-03-2000 11:50 AM PT (US) 
Hard Target
Wizard

I absolutely agree with you and either Jerry Goldsmith or John Williams scoring Tomb Raider. I doubt Williams would be interested in scoring something like that. I know Jerry would score it. Here are someother recommendations, Alan Silvestri (who no doubt has written exciting scores for the upcoming Reindeer Games and What Lies Beneath with Harrison Ford and Michelle Pfeffier), David Newman, Christopher Young (Get The Hurricane), John Frizzell, Mark Mancina, and James Horner. would be good choices.
posted 02-03-2000 12:03 PM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Wizard

I also think Bruce Broughton could be a good choice. After Goldsmith and Williams. Broughton's score for Lost In Space is great!
posted 02-03-2000 12:31 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Wizard

For almost any potential project, I always say "CHRISTOPHER YOUNG!" I want him to get so many opportunities and write so many scores that I'll finally get borderline sick of him! Except I won't because he's such a huge talent, and ... he does, I believe, represent the future of film music as we know it. We're drooling over Goldsmith, Williams and Horner today? Our descendants will be salivating over Christopher Young, even more than some of us do at present.There, I said it, and to quote Dave Foley, "I feel better for having said it!"
Looking forward to THE HURRICANE. (I know, I know, I should've seen it, but I haven't had time to see a movie since TOY STORY 2, awright? Stop yelling at me!)
posted 02-03-2000 12:35 PM PT (US) 
James

Wizard

Of course I always shout "Richard Band!" for these questions, but that's not being realistic. My second choice is David Newman.James
posted 02-03-2000 01:01 PM PT (US) 
SBD
Wizard

If the film ever gets made (knock on wood - have they chosen a lead YET?!), I would look forward to David Newman, Alan Silvestri, John Ottman or Graeme Revell in the music credit (and Catherine Zeta-Jones as Lara Croft!) A guy can dream, can't he?
posted 02-03-2000 02:20 PM PT (US) 
Dawk

Wizard

whoever it was, I forget his name, who scored the Lost World video game.. He should do it. I say that because he did a wonderful job bringing that sort of sound to a videogame, and I think he could do the same for a movie version of tomb raider.. the style I heard would fit the movie just perfectly, and I think that composer would have a easy time just nailing it.
posted 02-03-2000 02:23 PM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

Oh, God! And here I was, hoping to keep this score-centered and not casting choices-centered.Anyhow, I can't believe you would want Zeta-Jones in this picture (your opinion, of course, and I respect that). The obvious choice for Lara Croft is Elizabeth Hurley, who would nicely fill out Lara's wardrobe a heckuva lot better than Zeta-Jones.
Not to mention that Hurley's a lot easier on the eyes.
posted 02-03-2000 02:29 PM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Wizard

From what I've heard Erika Eleniak has been cast as Lara Croft. At this point I can't confirm that, but this was from the Hollywood Reporter a while back. The Reporter is usually pretty acurate, being the industry guide and all.
posted 02-03-2000 03:01 PM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

Really? Hmmm . . . Not sure whether I like that rumor or not. Body-wise, I'd say yeah, but isn't she a little too shirt?
posted 02-03-2000 03:44 PM PT (US) 
Dan Brecher

Wizard

Huh, I'm the only one who does not want this movie to get made then eh?
Hmmmm, well if it does happen, sure a Goldsmith score would go down very well. Also Don Davis would get my vote.Dan (UK)
NP: Angelas Ashes (****/*****)
posted 02-03-2000 04:15 PM PT (US) 
robin4

Wizard

Well, since I want Goldsmith and Williams to do everything else (they are the best, you know), I'd have to give props to Silvestri and maybe McNeely.
posted 02-03-2000 05:57 PM PT (US) 
TimT

Wizard

I nominate Robert Folk.
- Nuff Said
posted 02-03-2000 07:19 PM PT (US) 
DjC

Wizard

Well, no one should score Tomb Raider, for it should not be made, BUT, if someone had to score a crappy adaption, thta has useless hours of nonstop boiring action, then Hanz Zimmerman, or Goldsmith would fit the mold, aint nothing like 2.5 hours of crappy action score, that drags, and drags, and drags, don't get me wrong, i like Zimmerman, and i suppose Goldsmith, but action is there field, and dragging on and on seems to be there way...hehe
posted 02-03-2000 08:38 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Wizard

Ummm... DjC? Who is this Hanz Zimmerman you keep referring to? You realize his name is Hans Zimmer, right? BTW... Who should score Tomb Raider? David Arnold, of course!Jeron
[This message has been edited by Jeron (edited 04 February 2000).]
posted 02-03-2000 09:22 PM PT (US) 
Pete M

Wizard

I'd go with Goldsmith. Or maybe Marco Beltrami. It'd be great to see what he could do with a project like this, rather than yet another horror/slasher type film. Oh, yes!
And as for the casting, apparently it's already cast :
"They have their Lara Croft as well apparently - an unknown actress who's, so I'm told, in her early twenties and comes from a stage background. Her first name is Kim but other than that, I don't know."
From Dark Horizons news 2/2/00
np Sleepy Hollow[This message has been edited by Pete M (edited 04 February 2000).]
posted 02-04-2000 03:55 AM PT (US) 
Tom Scofield
unregistered
Is Andre L. there under a psuedonym?I don't know if Erika Eleniak is too "shirt," but she sure fills out a shirt! She would be a very interesting choice for Laura if she could handle the accent and looked good as a brunette.
I think the very underrated David Whitaker would write a great score for the movie!
[This message has been edited by Tom Scofield (edited 04 February 2000).]
posted 02-04-2000 12:28 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Wizard

I would have to agree with Jeron and say Davind Arnold. This is odd b/c I usually do not agree with Jeron about who should score upcoming movies (I am not of the mind that Goldsmith or Arnold do everything) but here is a point where Arnold jumps into mind. You know, I used to not like him - but now...
posted 02-04-2000 02:44 PM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

Oh, God, not David Arnold again! Unless it's in the vein of "StarGate," I would advise the filmmakers to stay as far away from Arnold as humanly possible.
posted 02-04-2000 02:50 PM PT (US) 
SEBULBA

Wizard

Uh oh! Sounds like Dantoris is hitting a soft spot with some of us. DAVID ARNOLD!!!
posted 02-04-2000 02:58 PM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

I'm not saying I hate Arnold. Everyone on this board can like/hate you they want. I love Arnold's early work - "StarGate" and "The Last of the Dogmen" - but the rest has failed to impress me. "Independence Day" had it's moments, but his Bond scores were absolute embarrasments to the franchise, "TWINE" more so than "TND." And it's a shame John Barry believes Arnold is the best person since him to score the Bond films.His mix of techno and orchestra are mind-numbling bad. He's obviously trying to make the scores sound contemporary by doing so, but it just makes them worse. If your going to take an orchestra and mix in so much techno-crap, you better make sure it's done well and suites the picture which, in the case of "TWINE," it doesn't.
posted 02-04-2000 03:10 PM PT (US) 
spikewall
unregistered
They should let the master of music, Jerry Goldsmith conduct the music for Tomb Raider! After all of the other movies he has scored, he might have enough time to do this score! It's going to sound awesome when it's finished!
posted 02-05-2000 12:16 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Wizard

I just wanted to share that I feel completely opposite of Dantoris. I hate David Arnold's earlier stuff. Stargate and everything around that time. Then came Independence Day which did have its moments (albeit few in my opinion) then he started writing really good stuff and he just keeps getting better. The World is Not Enough is his best work to date. It is fresh and exciting and original and new. Sure, in a few years we are going to look back and think it's incredibly dated. but for now...
At least it isnt all techno or all orchestra - both have been done. What he did with TWINE hasnt. if it has please let me know because I want it. I want anything that blends techno beats and orchestras.
NP Henry V
posted 02-06-2000 02:24 AM PT (US) 
SBD
Wizard

dantoris, I apologize, but, IMHO, it couldn't be helped. I stand by my post, and perhaps, I should've kept it to myself.
posted 02-06-2000 09:53 AM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

No need to apologize, SBD (for the Zeta-Jones thing?). It's not like I was offended or something. It was your opinion, and, like I said, I can respect everyone's opinion, whether or not their the same as mine.
posted 02-06-2000 10:03 AM PT (US) 
AaronR1074

Wizard

DjC,If you ever bash Zimmer again on this board I will make you feel so emotionaly withdrawn that Peter K will have to ban me for it...And that goes for all of you out there!
Zimmer has such a wide range of musical talent that its astounding. I mean, to go from The Thin Red Line to Prince of Egypt in the same year can't be beaten. And let's not forget the creative talent that went into the masterpiece, Crimson Tide.Here, more than anybody else, is THE prime choice to score this movie.
If you want to hear what I mean, go get the "Point of No Return" score/album. Those few score tracks will shake your home theatre, and bring tears to your eyes with emotion and drama. It's action packed, dramatic, and even alittle comical. Quite an interesting score, and probably one of his most underrated. Though not one of his best, I think the Tomb Raider score should reflect some of this music. Let's not forget this is a video game about running around in dungeons, solving puzzles, and killing things. We can't get TOO dramatic with it.
[This message has been edited by AaronR1074 (edited 07 February 2000).]
posted 02-07-2000 08:49 PM PT (US) 
Crono/Kyp

Wizard

I'm with David Arnold or James Newton Howard--Kyp
posted 02-07-2000 09:01 PM PT (US) 
SFT

Wizard

How about Shirley Walker? That would be interesting.SFT
posted 02-08-2000 01:05 AM PT (US) 
Cole

Wizard

Oh, just go ahead and say it SFT! We know who you really want to score it!
Dont beat around the bush and give names like Shirley Walker - next you'll be saying Steve Bartek should score it!

posted 02-08-2000 02:55 AM PT (US) 
Pete M

Wizard

According to Aint it cool, http://www.aint-it-cool-news.com/display.cgi?id=5389 Angelina Jolie has been cast as Lara Croft, with Simon ('Con Air') West directing. Does this mean we could be in for a MediaVentures score? I hope not, as I think that this really needs a big, old-fashioned orchestral score.np Predator 2 (on Voyages compilation)
[This message has been edited by Pete M (edited 08 March 2000).]
posted 03-08-2000 08:49 AM PT (US) 
SBD
Wizard

I really like the casting of Angelina Jolie and that's all I'm going to say about it.Y'know, Carter Burwell doesn't score many adventures; it would be nice to see what he does with this. I mean he worked with Simon West before. Why not again?
NP - Space Jam ***.5/*****
posted 03-08-2000 09:19 AM PT (US) 
dantoris

Wizard

Angelina Jolie!?!? Oh, man, come on.
posted 03-08-2000 10:05 AM PT (US) 
Bulldog
Wizard

Following THE MUMMY and even THE 13th WARRIOR, coming a decade after his kinetic KING SOLOMON'S MINES, there's no one better for action/adventure (or anything else seemingly at any particular moment?) than Jerry Goldsmith.That said, it sure would be nice to see a baby boomer guy make a John Williams-like leap to bombastic immortality with this one. I too would offer the names Broughton and James Newton Howard.
But also Debney, Ottman, and--listen closely folks--Tom Newman.
I think that young Thomas would be great for a film like this; he may never accept the challenge...but I sure wish he would. I think that too few appreciate his atmospheric and contemporary sound. He could rally more fans with a kick-back action/adventure score and album.
Oh well that's what I think.
posted 03-08-2000 11:05 AM PT (US) 
SBD
Wizard

No, Bulldog, that's a very interesting thought. A tad unreal but, as I posted earlier, "A guy can dream, can't he?"
posted 03-09-2000 05:57 AM PT (US) 
Kris

Wizard

So far only Burwell, Rabin and Mancina have composed for West. Mancina would be ok!As for John Debney: it took 32 posts before his name popped up?! What the ... He'd be my first choice! I just don't hope it'll be some stupid score kids would like, ie. techno or heavy metall...

posted 03-10-2000 05:27 AM PT (US) 
Pete M

Wizard

Woooo, pop goes the topic again.
Well, the trailer is here (complete with appropriate techno-style music - does anyone know what this is, btw), but I still don't know who's scoring it. Does anyone?Also, the trailer looks quite cool. Maybe not the most original thing, but it sure looks like it's going to be entertaining fun. What more could you ask for? And I was quite impressed by Jolie's accent too.
np Dragonheart: A New Begginging
posted 12-11-2000 09:34 AM PT (US) 
Quill
Wizard

How about Craig Armstrong?He seems to have the perfect balance of synth and choral that would work great with this movie...as campy and crappy as it probably will be.
posted 12-11-2000 10:58 AM PT (US) 
Scott

Wizard

How about Michael Giacchino?
Scottposted 12-11-2000 11:42 AM PT (US) 
JJH

Wizard

who should score Tomb Raider?I should dammit!
NP -- The Duellists, Howard Blake
posted 12-11-2000 04:45 PM PT (US) 
Timmer

Wizard

I think I would go with Tom Scofield on this one and say DAVID WHITAKER...some chance
Of the better possibilities I would say POLEDOURIS,BURWELL,DANNA and CHRIS YOUNG
...more than likely it'll be Trevor Rabid or Mark Masticater 
WILLIAMS,GOLDSMITH and HORNER would all be safe hand's but I would prefer it if none of them were involved!
Howsabout ELMER BERNSTEIN?....now there's a thought!

NP : On Deadly Ground - Poledouris
posted 12-11-2000 04:58 PM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
