-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
which one CD would you...
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: which one CD would you...

Cole

Oscar® Winner

ok, I have just started posting and now I am ready to start asking all of those strange questions that I have been known to ask
(and I want to hear everyones' opinion)
If you could introduce everyone to one CD what would it be?
What would you introduce to the non score lovers and (this is the interesting part) what would you introduce to all of us here who allready know so much about film scores?[This message has been edited by Cole (edited 19 January 2000).]
posted 01-19-2000 01:34 AM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

fine. I guess I will have to be the first on this matter.
If I could make everyone in the world own one CD it would be "Schindler's List." It is not necessarily my most played CD, but that would be it.
If I could make everyone at this site listen to one CD it would be "The Space Between Us" by Craig Armstrong. It also is not necessarily my most played CD but I think everyone should hear it just for its originality and shear beauty.
Close runners up would be Rufus Waignright or Ben Folds Five.
your turn...
posted 01-19-2000 01:42 AM PT (US) 
SFT

Oscar® Winner

For everyone: "Batman" by Danny Elfman.For every score-fan: "Dangerous Liaisons" by George Fenton.
SFT
posted 01-19-2000 01:53 AM PT (US) 
Timmer

Oscar® Winner

I've already done this to one person and it was Goldsmith's Planet of the Apes, But it was an educated guess based on my knowledge of what he liked.....he loved the score,But still is'nt a film music fan!On a broader base it would have to be Conan The Barbarian due to it's wealth of good and accesable tunes!
NP:The Truman Show
posted 01-19-2000 04:48 AM PT (US) 
Will

Oscar® Winner

I introduced two of my friends who wished to find out the beauty of scores, so I loaned them The Rock. (Not so much on beauty for that!)Other scores I also introduced are Legends of the Fall, The Phantom Menace and The Fabulous Baker Boys.
posted 01-19-2000 08:56 AM PT (US) 
Thor

Oscar® Winner

STAR WARS for the uninitiated "closet-fan"IMAGES (if I should pick only one) to the film music connaiseur (although he probably already owns that one). Just to show off Williams' remarkable versatility.
posted 01-19-2000 09:02 AM PT (US) 
Mark Hatfield
Oscar® Winner

Only ONE score?
Hmmmm.....
OK, call me weird, but I think it would probably have to be E.T. - THE EXTRATERRESTRIAL by Mr. Williams. I don't listen to this as much as some, but if I could have only one I am sure that I would never tire of listening to this one. It has all the requisites for me: quiet, pastoral cues; rousing, action-oriented passages; strong, memorable thematic material; and an incredibly strong music-to-image connection that always allows me to "see" the movie whenever I listen to it.
Of course, I'd rather be roasted alive than have only ONE score.....
NP: THE KEEP (Tangerine Dream) ****/*****
posted 01-19-2000 10:48 AM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

this is cool
my runners up for non score fans are: ET, Star Wars, The Rock and Batman. In that order!
Great minds...
posted 01-19-2000 12:34 PM PT (US) 
Scott

Oscar® Winner

Well, for everybody, either Star Wars or ET.
Perhaps even Raiders.For you guys, "Winnetou" by (gosh, the composers name escapes me rigth now). It's a German score for a German, Italien, French co-production. The main theme is quite good. The only one who probably knows this one is Floyd.
Scott
posted 01-19-2000 01:38 PM PT (US) 
Floyd Pepper

Oscar® Winner

my choice for both parties would be:
Michael J. Lewis' The First 25 Years, which is a beautifull collection of his themes. It's excellent for people who know nothing at all about film music (and would be streched too far with Chris Youngs' composition for Invaders from mars), but it would be also very interesting for real buffs, for it shows that even today there are some not so well known guys who write fine music that makes you remember the golden age of fm...Scott: Winnetou was scored by Martin Bottcher. He has done some nice music for German television, easy listening stuff of the sixties and seventies... (That is if we're talking about the same Winnetou...)
Floyd.
posted 01-19-2000 02:27 PM PT (US) 
spango

Oscar® Winner

JURASSIC PARK
THE PIANO
and BATMAN
posted 01-19-2000 02:31 PM PT (US) 
Dr.Evil

Oscar® Winner

Star Wars saga and Legend.
And if I had the time, The Mission and Legends of the Fall.
posted 01-19-2000 02:36 PM PT (US) 
robin4

Oscar® Winner

Well, if I wanted to get someone hooked, either The Rock or Star Wars depending on the person.
posted 01-19-2000 02:53 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

good good.
but you need to tell me what you would introduce to me. I allready know about star wars
posted 01-19-2000 05:12 PM PT (US) 
Wedge

Oscar® Winner

Bruce Broughton's expanded "Lost in Space"
Angela Morley's "Watership Down"
posted 01-19-2000 06:36 PM PT (US) 
Mark Hatfield
Oscar® Winner

Cole;
I've really been thinking about what I would "introduce" to score fans (as opposed to E.T. for non-score fans), and.....
I'm a bit stumped. Judging from the posts here, I have about the slimmest collection (only 250 or so CD's) and about the least true knowledge of music. Someone at another board which shall remain nameless once derided my tastes as "proletarian"; guess I'm just not in possession of a sophisticated musical palate. All of this is the long way of saying "I'm sure I can't really introduce you to ANYTHING". I might aim at fun vs. musical greatness, and try to inspire some appreciation of either BLUE THUNDER (Rubenstein) or CREEPSHOW (Harrison). The reason? Most folks just don't like electronic scoring....and wholly apart from budgetary concerns on the part of the film makers, I just feel that some electronic scores are RIGHT. While BLUE THUNDER is monothematic, it does possess a (to me) stirring main theme that is absolutely right for the film -- rousing, pulsing with ode-to-technology ambience, and memorable. As for CREEPSHOW, its integration into the action is necessary to help sustain the cheery dark carnival atmosphere....and the cue from "The Crate" segment, with its wild piano, is a showstopper.
Please put away poison pens/keyboards, folks. These are just my opinions, and I already know that I am in the minority when it comes to electronic scoring. I suggested the above two titles (ignoring Cole's request for just ONE; sorry, man!) only because I think they are fun, work well both inside AND apart from the films they represent, and are (opinion!) underrated.
Cole?NP: THE AGONY AND THE ECSTASY (North) 5/5*
posted 01-20-2000 04:04 PM PT (US) 
Cole

Oscar® Winner

Mark,
good answer (I am not strict on rules)
I hope if you are such a fan of electronic scoring that you will check out Vice DiCola's score to Transformers the Movie (I shamelessly plug this score all the time) because of its pulsating synth music and great themes. If you aim for fun then this is where you should set your sights! It makes me laugh and generally gets me going - and it does have some excellent playing on it. You can only get it online at Botcon.com (I think)[This message has been edited by Cole (edited 20 January 2000).]
posted 01-20-2000 04:32 PM PT (US) 
sabbey

Oscar® Winner

Hey Cole, I have that Transformers set. Yes it's very good.
Personally the CD I would introduce to people, would be Jerry Goldsmith's The Mummy. That is one of the few that when I got it, I told everyone I know, that they should get it.
Sean Robert Abbey
posted 01-20-2000 10:45 PM PT (US) 
Shaun Rutherford

Oscar® Winner

It'd be Goldsmith's Rio Conchos theme. I like Thor's idea with Images, though. One of the best scores I've ever heard!Shaun
NP---"A Friend From Mars" from Total Recall.
posted 01-20-2000 11:07 PM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Wedge, I'm still not that excited about "Lost in Space". I like it, but I don't find it that great. (For those who don't know, Wedge introduced me to that score at the FSM board).Hm, for those who are already familiar with Williams and Goldsmith, my choice would be Doyle's "Much Ado About Nothing". Other candidates are Debney's "Cutthroat Island" and Edelman's "Dragonheart".
posted 02-24-2000 05:52 AM PT (US) 
Ron Pulliam

Oscar® Winner

So m-a-n-y choices and way-y-y too little time:Return to Oz or The Natural.
Ron
posted 02-24-2000 02:16 PM PT (US) 
Jeron

Oscar® Winner

Unfortunately Ron, I can't find Return to Oz anywhere on the face of this planet. I've been looking forever.Jeron
posted 02-24-2000 02:24 PM PT (US) 
H Rocco
Oscar® Winner

My brother Mark, "proletarian?" Well, who knows. (That's better than "pedestrian.")Pfft, I've tried this kind of thing so many times. I've inundated my Chicago buddy (formerly-Chicago buddy, I should say, he's just pulled up stakes for Mexico) with stuff -- side A on the first one was Unknown Ifukube (whom he does like at least for the Godzilla stuff), side B was Unknown Masaru Sato -- to my great surprise, he responded more strongly to the Sato. Hence, I made a second tape of 100 RIFLES (side A) and PLANET OF THE APES (side B). I thought this was a fair range of Goldsmith's ability, and if he'd responded to Sato, it only made sense he'd respond to these. So I thought. He didn't hate them (or wouldn't tell me he did -- but then, he's moved away, hasn't he? Oh, there were other reasons, but still, I'm superstitious.)
You just never know what people are going to respond to. My father can't be bothered with nearly ANY form of film music, but he adores GRAND CANYON (both theme and movie leave me absolutely cold); and he responded surprisingly well to Christopher Young's DEF-CON 4 theme and Goldsmith's VOYAGER (but he's predisposed to like it, he also likes the show. Drives him nuts when I'm in the same room with it and start whistling along with the tune -- but I can't help it, it's one of the most infectious things I think I've ever heard, even if it's basically an inversion of Goldsmith's SHADOW theme from earlier the same year.)
NP: ENTER THE DRAGON (Lalo Schifrin, expanded)
posted 02-24-2000 02:26 PM PT (US) 
Wedge

Oscar® Winner

Marian, I wasn't all that excited about "Lost in Space" the first few listens either. But the more I played it, and the more I gave myself over to the music, the more it revealed its intricacies and complexities. Just listen to that moving cello line during "Will's Time Machine", for one example ... sheer brilliance!
posted 02-24-2000 02:28 PM PT (US) 
starblade

Oscar® Winner

I've actually used Goldsmith's The Twilight Zone: The Movie and William's Superman to introduce people to movie music. Those themes are preety well known by just about everyone. You get their interest by something familiar, and then you play not so well known scores for them, like The Black Hole, or Tron...
posted 02-25-2000 03:34 AM PT (US) 
Ron Pulliam

Oscar® Winner

Jeron: There's a "Return to Oz" CD being auctioned off on eBay right now.As of yesterday afternoon, the bid was not very high.
Ron
posted 02-25-2000 08:28 AM PT (US) 
Mark Hatfield
Oscar® Winner

Cool to see this thread still up.....Hiya, H Rocco! Nope, the description of my love for some electronic scoring was "proletarian, and un-informed". Obviously I have decided not to "retire" from posting, or sell off my collection & take up animal husbandry as a hobby. Who cares? I like what I like, and try never to offend in defense of my passions.

I know what you mean. My girlfriend LOVES all music (I'll take some credit for introducing her to film scores). She is crazy about Poledouris and Williams and Barry....but finds Goldsmith "too atonal". My fault here, as the first Goldsmith scores I loaned her were PLANET OF THE APES and POLTERGEIST. I have since gone crazy finding other Goldsmith scores for her to listen to; she now likes FIRST KNIGHT, THE 13TH WARRIOR, MULAN, and THE BLUE MAX. She will be going with me to the Detroit concerts in June, but I have the feeling that it is more out of love for me than excitement over the live performances. Great woman.

I still stand with my picks here, but the suggestion of THE NATURAL is a terrific one. Hard not to respond to all that wonderful Americana.....
You guys are great.
NP: RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK 5/5*
Considered for this thread, definitely. Simply my favorite movie and one of my favorite scores of all time. Just thought that E.T. - THE EXTRATERRESTRIAL was more Universal. Bad joke - sorry!
posted 02-25-2000 09:40 AM PT (US) 
Ron Pulliam

Oscar® Winner

Way back when (mid-80s), I'd sit friends down and try to explain to them why I got off on movie music.I'd open a nice bottle of wine, make sure everyone was calm and mellow, and then I'd preface the playing of a score with a little bit of the story...the size of it, the scope, and what the music they were about to hear said to me during the course of the film.
One friend and his wife were treated to "The Wind and the Lion" -- and that opening title just grabbed them, shook 'em all up and blew them away. They were mesmerized by the whole score. As the mood of the music changed, I'd give a short idea of the scene the music was written to accompany.
They loved it so much, they asked for a tape of the score and they shared a similar night with other friends at their home. They also asked for another night like that, so I cranked up "Mutiny on the Bounty" by Bronislau Kaper. (This was in the days when all we had were vinyl LPs). There were two cues I'd get really involved with to the point that I had my friends' attention so fully I could probably have hypnotized them....the Leaving Porstmouth Harbor sequence...and then the sequence when the Bounty crew lands in Tahiti....the crew comes ashore with all those ominous chords swirling around them, while on-screen the Tahitians swirled around the crewmen...it was an exhilarating experience for me and for my friends.
Years later (we were in the Navy and we went our separate ways to other tours of duty), our paths crossed again and they still remembered those nights...and they had become fans of, rather than collectors of, film music.
Ron
posted 02-25-2000 11:18 AM PT (US) 
Marian Schedenig

Oscar® Winner

Wedge, just giving it another try...
NP: Lost in Space: "Will's Time Machine"
posted 02-26-2000 08:59 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
