-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Score "adaptations" in rock movies
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Score "adaptations" in rock movies

Brad

Oscar® Nominee

I was just thinking about Detroit Rock City, which I haven't yet seen but was thinking about its plot and how it relates to the soundtrack. As with a number of movies over the years, this movie deals with rock music as a major plot element (that of KISS, in this case). So a lot of apprporiate music is featured on the soundtrack, but in the film and on CD. But what I'm wondering about is the nature of the score. It's by J. Peter Robinson, who's no stranger to this type of film; he did the score for Wayne's World, another movie featuring rock music in part. But as I can't remember much of Wayne's World and I haven't seen DRC at all, I would like to ask all of you: what are these scores like? Are they orchestral? Or do they mimic the rock music so prominently featured? The reason I ask this is because I noticed the credit for Miles Goodman on the "Footloose" CD as "score adaptation". Has anyone seen Footloose, too? Is it just instrumental retreads of the major songs? And what about (oh dear, excuse me for rambling) the scores for movies like Big Daddy, Never Been Kissed, She's All That and 10 Things I Hate About You? They're short, I'm sure, and usually nonexistent on CD, but I still wonder about the stuff score composers for song driven movies come up with. Just something I've been wondering about lately...
posted 08-19-1999 09:57 PM PT (US) 
TimT

Oscar® Winner

J. Peter Robinson's music for Detroit Rock City was completely orchestral,and even had a choir in one scene, and even a clip of O'Fortuna in another. But I think in the case of this film it needed an orchestra becuase the film is over-the-top dramatic( like when Jam's Mom was burning the tickets),and sometimes cartoon-like (like when Trip gets punched and flies up agianst the wall).
I've seen Wyanes World many times, but it was long before I was interested in score, so I don't remember anything about it.[This message has been edited by TimT (edited 08-20-99).]
posted 08-20-1999 07:34 AM PT (US) 
Norman McCay

Oscar® Winner

Brad,These song-driven movies, honestly, tick me off because they tease us with some orchestral stuff in the movie (I would only pay attention if it was actually good music, aside from accompanying the movie), and yet on the soundtrack they are nowhere to be found, like Scream 2.
Movies like Big Daddy, Never Been Kissed, and others like them are exactly what I am talking about. These movies --excuse the term--SUCK anyway, so sometimes I think that having orchestral music in them is like a waste of the composer's talent. I don't know about the rest of you, but that's just how I feel.
So maybe I didn't answer your question about HOW the scores sound in movies like Detroit Rock City or Big Daddy, but to me, the movie itself detracts me from paying any attention to the score because the music supervisiors don't see it as marketable...so they don't respect it anyway.
Of course, there are exceptions, with movies that come out with soundtracks that includes a suite from the composer combining the score with the songs, notably in Good Will Hunting, City of Angels, Patch Adams, Simon Birch, and other dramatic movies such as them. But because they were included, we never see a score release separate from the soundtrack. Pleasantville was the only one in my recent memory that did (Thank God)
Okay, that was my rant for the day....taking a deep breath now.
posted 08-20-1999 10:17 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
