-
Message Boards

Movie Soundtracks
Star Wars Soundtrack Question
Archive of old forum. No more postings.
Please visit our new forum, The MovieMusic Lobby, to post new topics.
Author
Topic: Star Wars Soundtrack Question

Norman McCay

Oscar® Winner

For all of those who own these John Williams masterpieces, I wanted to ask for your opinions. Which version of the released double disc-ed CDs should I get? Should I get the versions which contains two discs, but has less tracks (I believe it's around 12-13 each disc)? Or do I get the ones where there are two discs, but each disc contains around 20 or so tracks? I do plan on purchasing all three scores to the Trilogy, I just wanted to see if it's worth the extra five dollars for the longer CDs (with additional 7-8 tracks).
posted 05-24-1999 04:42 PM PT (US) 
Kevin
Oscar® Winner

Well, speaking as one who has all of the releases for the trilogy (CD's and LP's), I have this advice...If you want to get (nearly) everything that was recorded and released, you need to get the 4-disc boxed set that came out a few years ago, plus the 2-CD "Special Edition" ones.
However, if you just want the best (IMO) ones to get without getting "everything," go with the ones that were released when the Special Editions" came out in 1997.
Kevin
NP - Stargate SG-1posted 05-24-1999 05:21 PM PT (US) 
Norman McCay

Oscar® Winner

But which of the 1997 versions should I get? The longer 2-disc sets or the shorter 2-disc sets? The longer one's about $35 each, and $27 for the shorter ones. I saw the box set, and I wasn't sure if it contained everything. I am leaning towards the 1997 versions. But the longer version or the shorter version?
posted 05-24-1999 08:35 PM PT (US) 
Andy Lindahl

Oscar® Winner

They contain the exact same music. The reason one of the versions costs more, is that it is a limited edition. It's the same music.
posted 05-25-1999 02:00 AM PT (US) 
Maestro Sartori

Oscar® Winner

The 1997 Star Wars Trilogy Special Edition Soundtracks were priced for the original release of a book-form CD case, not the usual jewel case. There is now just the jewel 2-CD cases available, but it all has the same music on them.
posted 05-25-1999 02:37 AM PT (US) 
Audacity

Oscar® Winner

Norman,Andy is right, both 2-cd sets contain the exact same music. The cheaper sets that come in the jewel cases don't have more music they just have more tracks. For some reason they just divided the music up more, for example: track 2 on the more expensive (also called slimline) release is called MAIN TITLE/REBEL BLOCKADE RUNNER. While the less expensive (jewel case) release divided the two cues into two tracks, track 2 is MAIN TITLE and track 3 is REBEL BLOCKADE RUNNER.
Another difference besides the obvious packaging difference is the face of the CDs. The more expensive (slimline) release has really cool laser etched images on the face of the cd, while the less expensive release has the usual painted on images.
I have both releases. I originally bought the slimline release but later bought the less expensive release also because I got a great deal from columbia house on them. Now I am keeping the cooler looking laser etched CDs put away in case I ever damage or lose one of the other disks. Like Sartori said you might not be able to find the slimline release any more, they didn't make as many. But the important thing is that you buy one of the releases of this excellent music, it doesn't matter which release, if you are a Star Wars music or John Williams fan this is a must have.
Hope this has helped,
Audacity
N.P. Wyatt Earp (James Newton Howard)posted 05-25-1999 04:54 AM PT (US) 
Norman McCay

Oscar® Winner

Thanks for everyone's help. But let me see if I got this right....The difference between the two versions is that one divides its tracks into more tracks, while the other version links its tracks together into only one? So the play time is exactly the same?
posted 05-25-1999 09:37 AM PT (US) 
SFT

Oscar® Winner

Yes,
I do not have all the special releases but I have Return of the Jedi, because the normal release was out of print when I bought them. I had to pay 30 dollars for it!
But, I got the music so what the hell?
No matter wich one of the releases you bye (good luck finding the special one) it is great music and a must-have for any collector.SFT
posted 05-25-1999 10:00 AM PT (US) Old Infopop Software by UBB
